http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/the-public-deserves-answers-not-stonewalling-from-hillary-clinton/2015/03/09/5a829ddc-c67e-11e4-b2a1-bed1aaea2816_story.htmlBy Editorial Board March 9
A PARAMOUNT test for those running for president is how they make decisions — how they absorb information, what principles they carry and how it is all processed to a final choice. This is highly subjective, often lost in the hurly-burly of campaigning, but crucial. Hillary Rodham Clinton, who is expected to announce her candidacy soon for the Democratic nomination, is at one of those revelatory moments and so far seems not to have recognized it. On Monday, people in her circle suggested that she will soon answer questions about her e-mail account. We hope she seizes the opportunity to be forthcoming.
A week has passed since the disclosure that Ms. Clinton used a private account for all of her e-mail messages while serving as secretary of state, contrary to the administration’s instruction that officials should use government e-mail accounts and contrary to what the State Department — on her watch — was telling its ambassadors and other officials to do. Ms. Clinton did not turn in the e-mail records to the government when she left office. Since then, she has given the department 55,000 pages of messages in response to a request, but those were selected by her and her staff, not by government archivists or officials. All of this reveals a cavalier attitude to the public’s legitimate claim on government records.
In the past week, Ms. Clinton has said exactly this, in a tweet: “I want the public to see my email. I asked State to release them. They said they will review them for release as soon as possible.”
This perfunctory statement is even less helpful than it sounds. Ms. Clinton must know that the State Department will follow the Freedom of Information Act process to release her e-mails, requiring that they be scrutinized for sensitive information and that other agencies be consulted — a lengthy process, not likely to result in release any time soon.
The tweet also does not address a number of questions that Ms. Clinton should answer: Why did she use a private account? What discussions did she have with advisers and other State Department or White House officials about it? How many messages, if any, have been omitted from those turned over to the department? Will she permit a neutral arbiter — say, from the National Archives — to examine any withheld messages?
Some have portrayed the e-mail story as a conflict between Ms. Clinton and members of Congress who are investigating the attack on a U.S. mission in Benghazi, Libya, while she was secretary. But this is not primarily about Benghazi. Instead, it is about how Ms. Clinton responds to legitimate questions about her judgment and her record; it is about how she would function as president. Dispatching friendly politicians and former aides to television news shows to dismiss the issue as just politics does not help her cause. If she is elected president, can Americans expect a similar response when she faces difficult questions — one 26-word tweet and a cloud of obfuscation from her friends?
If she wants to demonstrate the strength of character and judgment required to be president, Ms. Clinton should hold a news conference and answer all the unanswered questions about her e-mails.
Read more on this issue:
Ruth Marcus: Hillary Clinton is again her own worst enemy
The Post’s View: Hillary Clinton’s use of private e-mail reflects poor judgment
Dana Milbank: Hillary Clinton, too cautious for her own good
Paul Waldman: Six questions Hillary Clinton must answer
Alexandra Petri: The real stunner from the Clinton e-mails
James Downie: Clinton is already repeating her 2008 mistakes
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
389 Comments
The Post Recommends
How parents create narcissistic children
Narcissists are bred, not born, by parents who tell them they are superior to others and deserve special treatment.
Robin Thicke, Pharrell Williams owe Marvin Gaye’s family $7.4 million for ‘Blurred Lines,’ jury decides
Jurors ruled that the 2013 hit too closely resembles a 1977 R&B classic.
PNC Bank loses Vienna man’s $100,000 check for 10 months, then ‘finds’ it
The bank appeared uninterested in restoring a longtime customer's money. Then The Washington Post called.
Trending on Social Media
Privacy advocates try to keep 'creepy,' 'eavesdropping' Hello Barbie from hitting shelves
Redskins free agency: Where things stand heading into Day 2
This 95-year-old man just killed the 200-meter sprint and set a world record
A coda to the Cotton letter
Islamic State claims slaying of Arab Israeli 'spy' in latest video
Leak investigation stalls amid fears of confirming U.S.-Israel operation
Discussion Policy 389 Comments
Mentioned in this story and want to comment? Learn more
Please Sign In to Comment
All Comments
Newest First
Pause live updates
d_lakedaddy
7:36 AM EDT [Edited]
If Hillary is being honest, she should have no problem handing the server over to the FBI for forensic analysis. We all know that is what she would demand from any opponent of hers.
LikeReplyShare
inchoate
7:24 AM EDT
The fact that this woman remains politically relevant is a sad, sad commentary on the electorate.
LikeReplyShare
2 ·
DisgustedwithElitism
7:12 AM EDT
The U.S. Constitution and the rule of law have made America the success it has been. Those principles have endured serious wounds in the past six years under BHO; we simply cannot afford another lawless administration on the heels of this one.
America can do better, and America must do better, than HRC.
LikeReplyShare
1 ·
kisja-pisja
1:00 AM EDT
If Palin wrote her own e-mails without assistance, how could anybody understand them even if they were totally transparent?
LikeReplyShare
Eric M Krehemker
12:22 AM EDT
So in other words, will HIllary be more of the same or different? I imagine she will be somewhat different than Obama, but the results if she is ever president will be the same, disaster.
LikeReplyShare
Get Opinions
Daily updates delivered just for you.
Advertisement
Most Read Opinions
1
GOP senators appear set on their own breakaway nation
2
Tom Cotton's grandstand play
3
GOP senators' letter to Iran is dangerous and irresponsible
4
Republicans are beginning to act as though Barack Obama isn't even the president
5
New questions for Clinton
Unlimited Access to The Post. Just 99¢
The Most Popular All Over
TIME
Lily James: My Cinderella Glass Slippers Didn’t Fit Me
WNYC - New York Public Radio
Yodels and Hockets
The Dodo
Carpenter Fired For Rescuing Raccoon Has No Regrets
Advertisement