Obsidian -
Re "You're applying traditional equity valuation concepts to an asset that isn't equity.". Correct - this is how you value any revenue earning asset - house, bond, car, company - ETH is a utility token, that we value in the exact same way. Not just you and me, but financial analysists, quant, AI, etc - we all apply this methodology.
Re "ETH doesn't represent a claim on corporate earnings." what ETH does is capture network revenue directly through a function of protocol-level fee burning and staking yields. So, basically like corporate stock buybacks and dividends, without relying on a centralized company and that value instead being attributed to an ETH token. So, yes its not equity in a company, but there is no "magical alchemy" here - laws of finance still apply, and as this is figured our, and the hype / misunderstandings or "monetary premium" as you call it, erodes, price will gravitate to fundamentals. So, we have:
• Fee Burning akin to "Stock Buybacks": a portion of every transaction fee (the base fee) is permanently destroyed. This reduces the circulating supply of ETH in proportion to network usage, mathematically accruing value to existing holders in the same way a company uses profits to buy back shares.
• Staking Rewards akin to "Dividends": Holders who stake ETH to validate transactions earn a native yield paid out from protocol issuance and unburned priority fees. Unlike corporate dividends, which require board approval, this cash flow is programmatically guaranteed by the network's code.
I know how to value assets and so you can be pretty sure about this. Does not mean Eth cannot go up, especially on short term sentiment - but eventually it gravitates to fair value, as all income earning assets do.
PS - re "celebrating another investor's misfortune", that's not my intent here. As you know, I have made huge effort to protect you, and other from losing money, and providing guidance for long term success. Do I like being proven right? Of course. But to be clear, I don't take any delight in all that you have been negatively impacted. Indeed, quite the opposite - you can find many quotes over the years, where I have urged you to "rip the band aid off".
You're overlooking something important: not everyone values ETH purely on TPS, transaction fees, fee burning and staking yields.
Some investors believe Ethereum could become a foundational layer of global financial infrastructure. They see potential in institutional adoption, tokenisation, stablecoins, settlement, collateral and even AI-driven economic activity.
And these aren't just fringe opinions.
Take Tom Lee of Fundstrat, for example. His publicly discussed Ethereum price targets and scenarios have included:
$10,500 in 2021.
$12,000–$15,000 in 2025.
$25,000–$50,000 in longer-term scenarios.
Even $250,000 in an extreme long-term scenario.
Some of his shorter-term targets have missed their deadlines. That's fair criticism. But the point is that serious market participants are willing to contemplate an Ethereum valuation that goes far beyond what conventional transaction-fee or revenue models might suggest.
Take me, for example. I believe ETH has the potential to reach $100,000. I'm not claiming that's guaranteed. I'm expressing a long-term view of what Ethereum could become and the monetary and strategic premium investors might eventually assign to it.
Here's my question:
Bitcoin's valuation isn't derived from corporate earnings, dividends or transaction-fee revenue. A substantial part of its value comes from monetary premium, scarcity, network effects and expectations about its future role in the global financial system.
Why is it perfectly acceptable to assign BTC that premium, but somehow irrational to believe ETH could develop its own monetary and strategic premium?
You can argue that Bitcoin deserves a greater premium. That's a legitimate investment thesis.
But you cannot simply exclude the possibility of an ETH monetary premium from your valuation model and then declare that you've calculated its objectively correct fair value.
You're not eliminating speculation from valuation. You're making your own assumptions about which forms of future value deserve recognition.
And those assumptions can be wrong too.