By the way, when silver was trading at $120, good luck actually getting that price for physical coins and bars. If you check reviews of local bullion dealers, many were offering significantly less. Their typical justification was volatility — they needed a buffer to manage risk and stay profitable.
In reality, you might have received closer to $90–$100 even when spot was at $120. Maybe a highly motivated buyer would pay spot, but that wasn’t the norm. It usually takes sustained price levels before the gap between spot prices and what dealers are willing to pay begins to narrow.
In theory, physical silver should trade at a premium to paper silver because of fabrication costs, logistics, and immediate availability. But in practice, that’s not how it plays out during sharp price moves — dealers widen spreads, manage inventory risk, and often bid well below spot despite those underlying premiums.