If you are replying to the op re who looks better that is one thing. Arguing about judging criterion is another thing and hopefully not so subjective.
You may prefer a type of physique but that doesn't mean it is better re judging criterion.
For example, Steve Reeves had a great physique that would not place in the Olympia today.
If I was a judge and Bob Paris walked out at his best at the 2018 Olympia I would place him first as that's my personal opinion, as a judge you cant do that, you have to toe the line...