everyone is missing the point here.
There is one problem and one solution and no it is not dieting, it is a matter of perception.
Mistakes were made by everyone he has ever worked with including Aaron and pj.
He keeps failing and he keeps looking the same because he is trying to dial in at 170lb. The second he gets it through his head that he is only 145lb shredded on stage progress will be made.
How can someone get shredded if they think they need to be 170lb, it won't work, perception is everything.
You might have seen more of Jason, I only watch a few vids here and there - but I've never seen him mention a certain weight at all. All I've seen is him struggle to do what he has been told to do, over and over again.
I do not agree that people are missing the point. I think if anything, you are missing the point that everybody is hammering.
Jason is not doing anything he is told. That is the point.
Jason has been given a full training and diet program and we see him turn up and begin a workout doing side raises and then shrugs? No way PJ gave him that.
Forget the side debate from TA on training hard being necessary - if he isn't following the training, he isn't following the dieting, either. You either have to eat less food (which can be uncomfortable) or burn off extra (which can be uncomfortable). There is no way Jason is doing either on a consistent basis.
I think TA is along the right lines with his 4 microwave dinners theory. The prescribed diet has to be so simple, even a muppet could follow. The guy does not look to have it in him to train consistently so you cannot trust him to eat more and you basically cannot trust him to prepare meals /etc.
But even then, only his mind can stop him from snacking and does he have that in him? Maybe not