Getbig.com: American Bodybuilding, Fitness and Figure
Getbig Main Boards => Gossip & Opinions => Topic started by: Fatpanda on February 28, 2008, 02:05:23 PM
-
1.dexter
2.heath
3.warrren
4. baddell
5. melvin
6 who cares?
-
1. Kai
-
I think the people who would pick Dexter over Phil Heath are mostly giving him credit for years of quality performances in bodybuilding, and while that may be the case, I don't think he is as good as Phil. Better conditioned, yes, better, no.
-
I think the people who would pick Dexter over Phil Heath are mostly giving him credit for years of quality performances in bodybuilding, and while that may be the case, I don't think he is as good as Phil. Better conditioned, yes, better, no.
I disagree. I believe that AT THIS MOMENT dex is superior to phil but phil may eventually eclipse dex.
Just not right now.
Both men have their structural flaws, heath is narrow, dex have high lats. Both have small frames.
In terms of bodyparts phil has noticebly better quads and calves. His arms are better too but its not like dex is a slouch in the guns department.
Dex has incredible delts, abs, chest and back, just too much for a young heath.
One of phil's strengths - his conditioning, really becomes a moot point with regards to dexter who is superior in that regard and whose density and quality far outshines a relatively inchoate heath who by comparison doesn't have that "finish" that dex has.
For this reason i say dexter for the win
-
1 Heath to win
2 Dexter
3 Branch
4 Melvin
5 Moe Moussoui
-
1 heath
2 dex
3 melvin
4 branch
5 moe
-
I disagree. I believe that AT THIS MOMENT dex is superior to phil but phil may eventually eclipse dex.
Just not right now.
Both men have their structural flaws, heath is narrow, dex have high lats. Both have small frames.
In terms of bodyparts phil has noticebly better quads and calves. His arms are better too but its not like dex is a slouch in the guns department.
Dex has incredible delts, abs, chest and back, just too much for a young heath.
One of phil's strengths - his conditioning, really becomes a moot point with regards to dexter who is superior in that regard and whose density and quality far outshines a relatively inchoate heath who by comparison doesn't have that "finish" that dex has.
For this reason i say dexter for the win
Those are good points. Dexter does have a lot of strengths for sure. Overall, I prefer Heath's look, and you be right that Heath is not quite ready. It would be easier to judge viewing them side by side. But I wouldn't doubt that Heath has a chance.
-
1)Dexter
2)Heath
3)Gustavo
4)Melvin
5)Kai
-
1 Dex
2 Heath
3 Branch (either 3rd or 4th, hopefully 3rd though)
4 Melvin
5 Moe
edit: fuck, forgot about Kai and Gustavo ;D
Tough line up thats for sure.
-
if even half the hype about Kai is true he should win this show and the Olympia easily. :D
-
I think the people who would pick Dexter over Phil Heath are mostly giving him credit for years of quality performances in bodybuilding, and while that may be the case, I don't think he is as good as Phil. Better conditioned, yes, better, no.
with respect matt i believe you are judging heath on what you think he will become not what he is currently. currently he is not better than dex.
-
with respect matt i believe you are judging heath on what you think he will become not what he is currently. currently he is not better than dex.
Not better in terms of conditioning...but I don't think he gives up a lot of size to Dexter. What do you think? Also, I prefer Phil's structure to Dexter's. Phil's relative narrowness is not as much of a flaw as Dexter's high and jutting lats in my opinion.
Let's also not rule out Branch Warren at the show:
(http://www.bodybuildingpro.com/2006arnoldclassicpumproomdvd/15.jpg)
2006 ARNOLD CLASSIC PUMP ROOM DVD:
http://www.bodybuildingpro.com/2006arnoldclassicpumproomdvdreview.html
MORE PICTURES:
http://www.bodybuildingpro.com/2006arnoldclassicpumproomdvd
-
Branch looks great there - only problem is the back usually lacks the hardness, separation and detail that is seen from the front.
-
1.who cares?
2.who cares?
3.who cares?
4. who cares?
5. who cares?
6 who cares?
-
1.who cares?
2.who cares?
3.who cares?
4. who cares?
5. who cares?
6 who cares?
Then fuck off ::)
-
1) KAI GREEEEEEEEENE!
-
1) KAI GREEEEEEEEENE!
Hahaha, imagine that.
-
1.Heath
2.Dexter
3.Kai
4.Gustavo
5.Melvin
Peace
D
-
My prediction
1.Dex
2.Phil
3.Branch
4.Melvin
5.Gustavo
-
1.Heath
2.Dex
3.Gustavo
4.Melvin
5.Kai
-
1.who cares?
2.who cares?
3.who cares?
4. who cares?
5. who cares?
6 who cares?
your cousin. ::)
-
Not better in terms of conditioning...but I don't think he gives up a lot of size to Dexter. What do you think? Also, I prefer Phil's structure to Dexter's. Phil's relative narrowness is not as much of a flaw as Dexter's high and jutting lats in my opinion.
Let's also not rule out Branch Warren at the show:
(http://www.bodybuildingpro.com/2006arnoldclassicpumproomdvd/15.jpg)
2006 ARNOLD CLASSIC PUMP ROOM DVD:
http://www.bodybuildingpro.com/2006arnoldclassicpumproomdvdreview.html
MORE PICTURES:
http://www.bodybuildingpro.com/2006arnoldclassicpumproomdvd
i think heath has great arms and legs, but his waist is slightly wider than it should be, his chest is small, his back is narrow and lacks thickness, and as you said his conditioning isn't as good as dex's.
dex i feel lacks calfs, although i dont think he has high lats, but i can see why you feel that, but i would ask that you look at the olympia 03 pics where he is compared with coleman, i think he looks like a smaller version from the back. overall i think dex as a perfectly balanced physique, and in my eyes thats what mr o and all champions should be 8)
anyway we don't have long to wait before we see tonights comparisons 8)
-
1.who cares?
2.who cares?
3.who cares?
4. who cares?
5. who cares?
6 who cares?
have you answered the facts about mohammed being a peadophile yet? ::)
-
have you answered the facts about mohammed being a peadophile yet? ::)
hamood is too busy sucking off his cousin to think about mohammed. ;D
-
if even half the hype about Kai is true he should win this show and the Olympia easily. :D
-
It will be the best stage appearance ever! :-X :-X
-
your cousin. ::)
Nope, Abdul-Basit doesn't care either.
-
sorry lads but ironman and arnold are too close
one bodybuilding show every 6 months or so is more than enough
NOW GET ME SOME PROTEIN
-
The old men in the back room want Dexter to win. If he comes in at 75% of what Phil has, then he'll take it. Maybe not fair, but I'm cool with that. 8)
-
I say Phil edges out Dex for the $130,000 grand prize & the 20th Annual title.
5-Melvin Anthony
3-Gustavo Badell
12-Adorthus Cherry
10-Toney Freeman
4-Kai Greene
12-Deshaun Grimez
1-Phil Heath
11-David Henry
2-Dexter Jackson
9-Johnnie Jackson
OUT-Victor Martinez
10-Desmond Miller
7-Ronny Rockel
6-Silvio Samuel
8-Branch Warren
OUT-Hidetada Yamagishi
-
1)Dexter
2)Heath
3)Gustavo
4)Melvin
5)Kai
BINGO!