Getbig.com: American Bodybuilding, Fitness and Figure

Getbig Main Boards => Politics and Political Issues Board => Topic started by: 240 is Back on November 10, 2009, 07:36:14 AM

Title: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: 240 is Back on November 10, 2009, 07:36:14 AM
What will they do to change things?

The common answer seems to be "Cut spending!" but that will result in a lot of jobs lost.  Remember the reason neither candidate in 08 would admit *where* they'd cut spending is because any cut in any sector means a lot of jobs get slashed.

SO if we're sitting at 12 or 15% official unemployment and the GOP takes over - what are they going to do, specifically?
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: BM OUT on November 10, 2009, 12:27:29 PM
What will they do to change things?

The common answer seems to be "Cut spending!" but that will result in a lot of jobs lost.  Remember the reason neither candidate in 08 would admit *where* they'd cut spending is because any cut in any sector means a lot of jobs get slashed.

SO if we're sitting at 12 or 15% official unemployment and the GOP takes over - what are they going to do, specifically?

It depends on what kind of republicans win.If its Lindsey Graham types nothing will change.If its Mike Pence types they will try to cut taxes.If its Ron Paul types they will eliminate everything.lol.Unfortuna tely I dont see too many Ron Paul types out there,so the only thing that will change is they can slow Obamas agenda but really do nothing.
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: 240 is Back on November 10, 2009, 12:31:22 PM
It depends on what kind of republicans win.If its Lindsey Graham types nothing will change.If its Mike Pence types they will try to cut taxes.If its Ron Paul types they will eliminate everything.lol.Unfortuna tely I dont see too many Ron Paul types out there,so the only thing that will change is they can slow Obamas agenda but really do nothing.

So what if they cut taxes?

What will NY, Cali, and other cash-strapped govts do if suddenly 20% of their income is gone?  They're close to collapse now.
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: Colossus_500 on November 10, 2009, 12:32:23 PM
It depends on what kind of republicans win.If its Lindsey Graham types nothing will change.If its Mike Pence types they will try to cut taxes.If its Ron Paul types they will eliminate everything.lol.Unfortuna tely I dont see too many Ron Paul types out there,so the only thing that will change is they can slow Obamas agenda but really do nothing.
Mike Pence or bust!
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: Kazan on November 10, 2009, 12:39:35 PM
So what if they cut taxes?

What will NY, Cali, and other cash-strapped govts do if suddenly 20% of their income is gone?  They're close to collapse now.

What does cutting Federal taxes have to do with state and local taxes?
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: Soul Crusher on November 10, 2009, 12:40:53 PM
So what if they cut taxes?

What will NY, Cali, and other cash-strapped govts do if suddenly 20% of their income is gone?  They're close to collapse now.

240 - our income in NY is already down 30%.  They need to cut spending to reflect the income and obtain concessions from state workers and cut the crap spending. 
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: tonymctones on November 10, 2009, 12:44:49 PM
cutting spending doesnt mean lost jobs 240 and when the stimulus provides 1.5 million to create 3 jobs i think those jobs we could do without  ::)

cutting wasteful spending and actually targeting bringing the economy back online with the spending you do have is what needs to be done. I think we can all agree that the stimulus has done next to nothing and when you take into account the debt we are worse off then we were...
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: 240 is Back on November 10, 2009, 12:56:40 PM
cutting spending doesnt mean lost jobs

Really? 

Is this general statement true?

You can cut spending without cutting jobs?

Let's leave out all the talk about the stim package, obama, etc.  When a GOP candidate promised to cut spending in a major way - what is exactly going to get cut?  My understanding is that projects deemed wasteful (that still employ people) are the ones that get slashed.  This is, again, why neither candidate will admit WHERE the spending will be cut.  Because people in that sector will lose jobs.
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: BM OUT on November 10, 2009, 12:58:17 PM
So what if they cut taxes?

What will NY, Cali, and other cash-strapped govts do if suddenly 20% of their income is gone?  They're close to collapse now.

Cutting taxes generates more revunue to the government,not less.This is lib lie.The problem is,as revenues go up,the dummies in the government spend more of it.
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: Soul Crusher on November 10, 2009, 12:58:45 PM
Cutting taxes generates more revunue to the government,not less.This is lib lie.The problem is,as revenues go up,the dummies in the government spend more of it.

That is definately the problem. 
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: tonymctones on November 10, 2009, 03:09:46 PM
Really? 

Is this general statement true?

You can cut spending without cutting jobs?

Let's leave out all the talk about the stim package, obama, etc.  When a GOP candidate promised to cut spending in a major way - what is exactly going to get cut?  My understanding is that projects deemed wasteful (that still employ people) are the ones that get slashed.  This is, again, why neither candidate will admit WHERE the spending will be cut.  Because people in that sector will lose jobs.
No 240 youre wrong cutting programs may lead to some lost jobs but cutting spending doesnt necessarily have to lead to cutting jobs...the two are not mutually exclusive.

and again wasteful spending as in the stimulus or other inefficient govt programs are doing more harm than good so losing a 3 jobs that cost the tax payers 1.5 million will be a net gain  ;)

LOL who knows what exactly will be cut? you didnt seem to care much about where exactly the stim money would be spent  ::) what are you worried about now?

youre wrong about the neither candidate comment, wrong b/c only one candidate is looking as cutting spending...and there isnt a D by their name  ;)
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: GroinkTropin on November 10, 2009, 08:02:21 PM
240- IMMEDIATELY give all small businesses a 1 year tax deference. You don't skip paying taxes, you just have a year without them and afterwords you can pay for the year over a short period of time. Business owners will gobble this up- with the freed revenue they can get some employees and start humming again. The econ improves and when the taxes need to be re-paid there is money to do so. It's the most basic economic principle you could think of. Keep in mind how unfriendly this country and certain areas in particular are to businesses. Think of all the countries like germany or france who would like to invest here and get some factories built but they would never make any money! Make the country business friendly to both foreign and domestic companies and you have your answer. Tax and spend is ludicrous but more-so is print what's not there and spend it, then force some absurd and costly medical program on americans that we don't even want. And pay for a useless war and blah blah. Obama is doing everything wrong. He panders to special interests and that's about it. He is useless. I knew he was a one term prez from the start and I will be happy when he fails.
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: 240 is Back on November 10, 2009, 08:08:59 PM
Methyl, those are some seriously great ideas.
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: Eric2 on November 10, 2009, 10:33:34 PM
  The best thing to do would be what Ronald Reagan did when the economy was far worse the day he took office than it was when Obamination took office. Cut taxes and regulations on business.
    Facts are facts, this really worked. It's history................. .what amazes me is that we are not doing this now.  Well actually it does not amaze me as the real goal hear by our current administration is to not really help us but to break our backs and make us into dependants of the government.
    Socialism is hear and rising. God help us all.
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: Soul Crusher on November 11, 2009, 04:55:19 AM
240- IMMEDIATELY give all small businesses a 1 year tax deference. You don't skip paying taxes, you just have a year without them and afterwords you can pay for the year over a short period of time. Business owners will gobble this up- with the freed revenue they can get some employees and start humming again. The econ improves and when the taxes need to be re-paid there is money to do so. It's the most basic economic principle you could think of. Keep in mind how unfriendly this country and certain areas in particular are to businesses. Think of all the countries like germany or france who would like to invest here and get some factories built but they would never make any money! Make the country business friendly to both foreign and domestic companies and you have your answer. Tax and spend is ludicrous but more-so is print what's not there and spend it, then force some absurd and costly medical program on americans that we don't even want. And pay for a useless war and blah blah. Obama is doing everything wrong. He panders to special interests and that's about it. He is useless. I knew he was a one term prez from the start and I will be happy when he fails.

BANG!

We need to reindustrialize and build many new factories, nuke plants, and attract foreign investors.

Right now the message of the govt to everyone is a big "FUCK YOU!"  

Businesses and investors are acting accordingly and voting with their dollars.  
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: Hugo Chavez on November 11, 2009, 05:01:11 AM
BANG!

We need to reindustrialize and build many new factories, nuke plants, and attract foreign investors.

Right now the message of the govt to everyone is a big "FUCK YOU!"  

Businesses and investors are acting accordingly and voting with their dollars.  
nuke  plants?
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: Soul Crusher on November 11, 2009, 05:09:28 AM
nuke  plants?

Nuclear power is very clean by todays standards, Europe already uses it with no problems.  It is cheaper and cleaner than coal and can provide sufficient energy to power any innovations in electric cars etc that may come accross.

Right now, electric cars would be fueled by coal since many electric plants are coal fired as it is.       
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: GroinkTropin on November 11, 2009, 12:54:50 PM
BANG!

We need to reindustrialize and build many new factories, nuke plants, and attract foreign investors.

Right now the message of the govt to everyone is a big "FUCK YOU!"  

Businesses and investors are acting accordingly and voting with their dollars.  

Yup. Obama has mostly been concerned with the following (in order).

1. Bailing out his rich buddies from losing their asses with their atrocious investments. Does he really believe in zero risk investing? Well of course not nobody does. Unless you buy a president and put him into office...
2. His popularity.
3. Forcing socialized medicine on us whether we want it or can afford it or not.
4. Running around the world apologizing for the horrible monster that is America and all the horrible things we have done.
5. Taking away our guns (thought not quite there yet. His attention is on step 3 and 4 right now). Give him a year. When it gets closer to 2012 and he is for sure a one term prez watch how motivated he becomes and how much media brainwashing comes out of nowhere.

You notice I did not include
1. A strong US dollar
2. A strong and viable military
3. Responsible gov spending
4. The viability of american businesses
5. Strong borders
6. Our future

They were omitted for a reason- he does not care! The facts are staring you straight in the face if you open your fucking eyes.
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: Soul Crusher on November 11, 2009, 01:03:45 PM
Yup. Obama has mostly been concerned with the following (in order).

1. Bailing out his rich buddies from losing their asses with their atrocious investments. Does he really believe in zero risk investing? Well of course not nobody does. Unless you buy a president and put him into office...
2. His popularity.
3. Forcing socialized medicine on us whether we want it or can afford it or not.
4. Running around the world apologizing for the horrible monster that is America and all the horrible things we have done.
5. Taking away our guns (thought not quite there yet. His attention is on step 3 and 4 right now). Give him a year. When it gets closer to 2012 and he is for sure a one term prez watch how motivated he becomes and how much media brainwashing comes out of nowhere.

You notice I did not include
1. A strong US dollar
2. A strong and viable military
3. Responsible gov spending
4. The viability of american businesses
5. Strong borders
6. Our future

They were omitted for a reason- he does not care! The facts are staring you straight in the face if you open your fucking eyes.


Damn bro -  you need to post here more often! 
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: The Showstoppa on November 11, 2009, 01:05:29 PM
Damn bro -  you need to post here more often! 

We are actively recruiting Mike to move to NC as we speak... 8)
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: Soul Crusher on November 11, 2009, 01:11:32 PM
We are actively recruiting Mike to move to NC as we speak... 8)

Funny you say that.  A buddy of mine moved from NYC to Cary, NC and I spoke to him last night and he said living in NYC is like a war zone compared to NC.   

I guess I exhibit battle fatigue in my own way with the crap I deal with.   I am so trying to get our of here.   
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: The Showstoppa on November 11, 2009, 01:15:03 PM
Funny you say that.  A buddy of mine moved from NYC to Cary, NC and I spoke to him last night and he said living in NYC is like a war zone compared to NC.   

I guess I exhibit battle fatigue in my own way with the crap I deal with.   I am so trying to get our of here.   

My brother just moved to Cary from Cali.....he loves it.  I live in Raleigh, which Cary basically merges into.
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: Soul Crusher on November 11, 2009, 01:17:06 PM
My brother just moved to Cary from Cali.....he loves it.  I live in Raleigh, which Cary basically merges into.

I am sick of NYC.  I have been here my whole life and its just too much.  The costs, the hustle and bustle, the chaos, the liberal bs. 

I want to have a ranch with acres, streams, and mountains.  The concrete jungle just aint cutting it any more.   
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: The Showstoppa on November 11, 2009, 01:19:17 PM
I am sick of NYC.  I have been here my whole life and its just too much.  The costs, the hustle and bustle, the chaos, the liberal bs. 

I want to have a ranch with acres, streams, and mountains.  The concrete jungle just aint cutting it any more.   

I can only imagine.  I need to move to North Dakota......build a compound....hahaha
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: Soul Crusher on November 11, 2009, 01:21:11 PM
I can only imagine.  I need to move to North Dakota......build a compound....hahaha

Sign me up! 

You ever see "Do the Right Thing"?  Its sort of like that all the fucking time. 
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: The Showstoppa on November 11, 2009, 01:24:09 PM
Sign me up! 

You ever see "Do the Right Thing"?  Its sort of like that all the fucking time. 


Ouch!  I remember that movie.  I have been to most larger US cities, but only flown thru NYC.  I'm just not big a fan of that much humanity in one place.  Brings out the worst in people.
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: Soul Crusher on November 11, 2009, 01:27:19 PM
Ouch!  I remember that movie.  I have been to most larger US cities, but only flown thru NYC.  I'm just not big a fan of that much humanity in one place.  Brings out the worst in people.

Its crazy bro.  There are something like 26 million people living in 50 mile radius or some shit like that. 

Its a blessing in that I have more street knowledge and sense for ten lifetimes, but its also a curse in that I am always sizing people up, suspicious of shit, looking for angles on things, looking around corners and in door frames, etc.     
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: The Showstoppa on November 11, 2009, 01:43:43 PM
Its crazy bro.  There are something like 26 million people living in 50 mile radius or some shit like that. 

Its a blessing in that I have more street knowledge and sense for ten lifetimes, but its also a curse in that I am always sizing people up, suspicious of shit, looking for angles on things, looking around corners and in door frames, etc.     

I know exactly what you mean.  When people from NYC move down here, they are so thrown off by people actually saying hello, or how are you?  they look at you like just slapped them...haha.  I refuse to change how I am, as they are the ones who moved here, not the other way around.  The ones who embrace the way people act here absolutely love it.....if not, get ready for some grief.
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: 240 is Back on November 11, 2009, 01:47:17 PM
You notice I did not include
2. A strong and viable military

great post man - your contributions here are great. 

But this one point - I thought Obama was like bush II when it came to military spending and troops everywhere- he hasn't changed a thing.  In fact, more troops to afghanistan. 
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: GroinkTropin on November 11, 2009, 01:47:31 PM
We are actively recruiting Mike to move to NC as we speak... 8)

I'm leaning that way. I'm finishing my undergrad before beginning nursing school. Some nice medical programs out there. Beautiful area. I'll have to fly out in a couple months and spend a few days there. I just spent 3 days in Seattle area. Nice place but far too cold and rainy. 35% chance I would like living there.
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: Soul Crusher on November 11, 2009, 01:48:47 PM
People wonder how I know so much about stuff, its just living here you deal with so much so soon, so often, you just adapt.  

I mean Geithner lives 8 minutes from here, Scarsdale and Greenwich 15 minutes away, Harlem and S. Bronx 10 minutes.  Wall Street 20 minutes down the West Side.

I live minutes away from DMX, Mary J. and P Diddy.

I got the whole deal over here.      

Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: The Showstoppa on November 11, 2009, 01:49:55 PM
I'm leaning that way. I'm finishing my undergrad before beginning nursing school. Some nice medical programs out there. Beautiful area. I'll have to fly out in a couple months and spend a few days there. I just spent 3 days in Seattle area. Nice place but far too cold and rainy. 35% chance I would like living there.

December thru March is not the best, as far as weather and how scenic it is.  But the fall and spring are awesome and you can travel all over from this location.  Glad to hear you are giving it a shot.  PM me if you have any specific questions or things I might be able to help with.
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: GroinkTropin on November 11, 2009, 01:51:58 PM
great post man - your contributions here are great. 

But this one point - I thought Obama was like bush II when it came to military spending and troops everywhere- he hasn't changed a thing.  In fact, more troops to afghanistan. 

He's sending more troops because he is being told to do so. Also since when does sending 10's of thousands of our troops overseas make our military any more viable? If anything it weakens it as we are less capable of defending an attack on our home soil. I think cutting our losses and honoring our dead who made huge sacrafices is the best way from here. Time heals all wounds. Just blowing more cash and losing more lives for a futile goal is not going to accomplish anything. Once the war drum starts it's hard to stop but it must be stopped. We can no longer afford it. Our troops are sick of the whole thing and financially we cannot keep paying hundreds of billions with no foreseeable return. I don't like it one bit.
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: Soul Crusher on November 11, 2009, 01:54:32 PM
He's sending more troops because he is being told to do so. Also since when does sending 10's of thousands of our troops overseas make our military any more viable? If anything it weakens it as we are less capable of defending an attack on our home soil. I think cutting our losses and honoring our dead who made huge sacrafices is the best way from here. Time heals all wounds. Just blowing more cash and losing more lives for a futile goal is not going to accomplish anything. Once the war drum starts it's hard to stop but it must be stopped. We can no longer afford it. Our troops are sick of the whole thing and financially we cannot keep paying hundreds of billions with no foreseeable return. I don't like it one bit.

Either do the job for a completion or dont do it at all. 
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: Soul Crusher on November 11, 2009, 02:03:35 PM
December thru March is not the best, as far as weather and how scenic it is.  But the fall and spring are awesome and you can travel all over from this location.  Glad to hear you are giving it a shot.  PM me if you have any specific questions or things I might be able to help with.

Another thing Show - I have lived amongst obama types my whole life.  Whether it be the Columbia and NYU types or the Brooklyn Barbara Boxer types, I know these people, who they are, and what they are about.  They are Stalinists at heart and abhor the founders and the constitution. 

Many people get on me for my fierce loathing of this man in the WH.  Its because I know what he's about and whats behind him that i cant stand him and hate what he is doing and the ends he seeks. 

If you ever listen to Michael Savage, he is sort of like me, we grew up amongst the red diaper doper babies and know them far better than people in middle america who see only a shiny face and a smile.  They are like the sheep ready for slaughter.  They have no idea they let a wolf in the pen. 

I truly feel sorry for the people are are not yet awoken to the horror that is upon us with this communist radical.   
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: The Showstoppa on November 11, 2009, 02:16:57 PM
Another thing Show - I have lived amongst obama types my whole life.  Whether it be the Columbia and NYU types or the Brooklyn Barbara Boxer types, I know these people, who they are, and what they are about.  They are Stalinists at heart and abhor the founders and the constitution. 

Many people get on me for my fierce loathing of this man in the WH.  Its because I know what he's about and whats behind him that i cant stand him and hate what he is doing and the ends he seeks. 

If you ever listen to Michael Savage, he is sort of like me, we grew up amongst the red diaper doper babies and know them far better than people in middle america who see only a shiny face and a smile.  They are like the sheep ready for slaughter.  They have no idea they let a wolf in the pen. 

I truly feel sorry for the people are are not yet awoken to the horror that is upon us with this communist radical.   

I used to listen to Savage on my drive home...he often cuts thru all the bullshit.  And I agree with you.  I've had the opportunity to travel and live in many different places.....rub elbows with some "elite" on occasion.....and they were hands down the worst.  At least rednecks are upfront about their thoughts, these people would preach equal rights and how disenfranchised some people were, yet they lived in gated communities and were the first to trash the "locals" as being beneath them.

One night at a dinner party I hadn't said very much and after half the room chuckled over their brie and chardonnay at how "ignorant" the locals were, someone asked where I was from.....after finding out NC....they all backtracked and stumbled all over themselves.  Idiots.... and the sad part was that if you got them out of their only comfort zone of science, they were completely lost.
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: 240 is Back on November 11, 2009, 02:19:18 PM
I think cutting our losses and honoring our dead who made huge sacrafices is the best way from here.

Most people would consider this a liberal strategy.

They'd say the terrorists would be laughing at us, the whole world would see us as weak.
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: Soul Crusher on November 11, 2009, 02:21:44 PM
I used to listen to Savage on my drive home...he often cuts thru all the bullshit.  And I agree with you.  I've had the opportunity to travel and live in many different places.....rub elbows with some "elite" on occasion.....and they were hands down the worst.  At least rednecks are upfront about their thoughts, these people would preach equal rights and how disenfranchised some people were, yet they lived in gated communities and were the first to trash the "locals" as being beneath them.

One night at a dinner party I hadn't said very much and after half the room chuckled over their brie and chardonnay at how "ignorant" the locals were, someone asked where I was from.....after finding out NC....they all backtracked and stumbled all over themselves.  Idiots.... and the sad part was that if you got them out of their only comfort zone of science, they were completely lost.


Where I live, i am literally wedged in between wealth like you wouldnt imagine, Greenwich, Scarsdale, etc, and just south of me is the South  Bronx and Harlem.  To my immediate left is Mt. Vernon.  Then a little further south is Wall Street and the Upper East & West Side gang. 

I see it all bro and know the deal far more than most of the people on this board.     
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: GroinkTropin on November 11, 2009, 04:25:42 PM
Most people would consider this a liberal strategy.

They'd say the terrorists would be laughing at us, the whole world would see us as weak.

I can understand this but which is worse- committing many billions of dollars and sending in our troops with their hands tied behind their backs or just coming to the logical conclusion that it's better to let the savages just wipe themselves out? I mean honestly have terrorists been lauging at Russia for bailing on afganistan? I'm all for seeing the job to completion, but let our boys do what they know they should. My buddy is a capt in the MC and he used to tell me all kinds of BS like you cannot chase after somoene if you lose line of sight. Do not fire unless fired upon etc. Remove the handcuffs and I say go for it. Send us over there half crippled and it's a huge waste of time. Sending 40k more troops now is a bad idea.
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: Straw Man on November 11, 2009, 06:11:46 PM
simple solution

let's stop wasting money on the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan

roll back the Bush Tax Cuts
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: 240 is Back on November 11, 2009, 07:41:57 PM
I can understand this but which is worse- committing many billions of dollars and sending in our troops with their hands tied behind their backs or just coming to the logical conclusion that it's better to let the savages just wipe themselves out? I mean honestly have terrorists been lauging at Russia for bailing on afganistan? I'm all for seeing the job to completion, but let our boys do what they know they should. My buddy is a capt in the MC and he used to tell me all kinds of BS like you cannot chase after somoene if you lose line of sight. Do not fire unless fired upon etc. Remove the handcuffs and I say go for it. Send us over there half crippled and it's a huge waste of time. Sending 40k more troops now is a bad idea.

I agree there is nothing more to be gained in iraq and afghanistan. 

Keep the bases, let their forces deal with the riff raff in cities, and let the war lords do their thing. 

But can you imagine the 3-year mocking Obama would get from Rush, hannity and friends for "quitting" on the wars?  For "declaring Defeat!"   I can hear it now.  The 2012 candidate would rub his nose in it too - even if it makes sense.
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: Kazan on November 11, 2009, 08:04:26 PM
I agree there is nothing more to be gained in iraq and afghanistan. 

Keep the bases, let their forces deal with the riff raff in cities, and let the war lords do their thing. 

But can you imagine the 3-year mocking Obama would get from Rush, hannity and friends for "quitting" on the wars?  For "declaring Defeat!"   I can hear it now.  The 2012 candidate would rub his nose in it too - even if it makes sense.

Afghanistan is a black hole for a foreign military, every army that has tried to conquer that shit hole has been bled dry and left. IMHO you pull out the ground forces and a scorched earth policy with air power and be done with the fuckers. What the government doesn't seem to undertand is you can't win the hearts and minds of people who's culture and religion brand all non Muslims as infidels. 

The US tries to play by the rules when no one else is.
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: 240 is Back on November 11, 2009, 08:19:45 PM
Afghanistan is a black hole for a foreign military, every army that has tried to conquer that shit hole has been bled dry and left. IMHO you pull out the ground forces and a scorched earth policy with air power and be done with the fuckers. What the government doesn't seem to undertand is you can't win the hearts and minds of people who's culture and religion brand all non Muslims as infidels. 

The US tries to play by the rules when no one else is.

All correct.

However, the 2012 repub candidate, as well as FOX news, beck, hannity, and Rush will spend the next 37 months talking about how Obama "surrendered to the terrorists".

We all know it's true. 

if he wants to have any chance of winning in 2012, he can't give them that card.  It sucks, and personally, i'd end the war tomrrow (and keep some bases of course).

But we all know they'll never let him hear the end of it.  They'll cal lhim every name in the book for leaving. 
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: Kazan on November 11, 2009, 08:36:35 PM
All correct.

However, the 2012 repub candidate, as well as FOX news, beck, hannity, and Rush will spend the next 37 months talking about how Obama "surrendered to the terrorists".

We all know it's true. 

if he wants to have any chance of winning in 2012, he can't give them that card.  It sucks, and personally, i'd end the war tomrrow (and keep some bases of course).

But we all know they'll never let him hear the end of it.  They'll cal lhim every name in the book for leaving. 

I'm sure that the way it would go, but in the mean time American soldiers pay the price for political advantage. I don't want either party controlling things. The sad truth of the matter is neither can be trusted and need to be put in check by the other party
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: 240 is Back on November 11, 2009, 08:45:02 PM
I'm sure that the way it would go, but in the mean time American soldiers pay the price for political advantage. I don't want either party controlling things. The sad truth of the matter is neither can be trusted and need to be put in check by the other party

both sides politicize the troops, that's nothing new.

It sucks for obama - do the right thing and pull them out of afghanistan and they'll destroy him and call him a coward and tell america he betrayed the soldiers by failing their mission.

Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: tonymctones on November 11, 2009, 08:48:39 PM
both sides politicize the troops, that's nothing new.

It sucks for obama - do the right thing and pull them out of afghanistan and they'll destroy him and call him a coward and tell america he betrayed the soldiers by failing their mission.


right but one side politicizes them in both negative and positive ways and one side in positive...Ill let you figure out which is which  ::)

fact is one side uses the troops one day and throws them under the bus the next
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: Kazan on November 11, 2009, 08:49:57 PM
both sides politicize the troops, that's nothing new.

It sucks for obama - do the right thing and pull them out of afghanistan and they'll destroy him and call him a coward and tell america he betrayed the soldiers by failing their mission.



Obama doesn't need any help being destroyed, he is doing fine job all by himself. He painted himself into a corner long ago, when he decided that is was a good idea to say that Afghanistan was the good and just war, when the Iraq war wasn't going so well. Policticians make me want to vomit
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: GroinkTropin on November 12, 2009, 01:46:11 PM
both sides politicize the troops, that's nothing new.

It sucks for obama - do the right thing and pull them out of afghanistan and they'll destroy him and call him a coward and tell america he betrayed the soldiers by failing their mission.



He can get away with it if he has enough faith that his other programs will be successful. For example if his healthcare plan takes off and the econ rebounds he could weather the storm. Things aren't looking good considering he won't gamble.
Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: 240 is Back on November 12, 2009, 06:20:37 PM
He can get away with it if he has enough faith that his other programs will be successful. For example if his healthcare plan takes off and the econ rebounds he could weather the storm. Things aren't looking good considering he won't gamble.

Good point.  IF healthcare is successful and we're back at 7% unemployment in 2012, people could be happy enough to keep him in.

Title: Re: If/When the GOP takes over in 2010 or 2012...
Post by: drkaje on November 12, 2009, 06:29:06 PM
What will they do to change things?

The common answer seems to be "Cut spending!" but that will result in a lot of jobs lost.  Remember the reason neither candidate in 08 would admit *where* they'd cut spending is because any cut in any sector means a lot of jobs get slashed.

SO if we're sitting at 12 or 15% official unemployment and the GOP takes over - what are they going to do, specifically?

Cut taxes and increase the deficit.