Getbig Bodybuilding, Figure and Fitness Forums

Getbig Bodybuilding Boards => Nutrition, Products & Supplements Info => Topic started by: MCat on October 29, 2005, 12:52:02 PM

Title: best overall protein powder
Post by: MCat on October 29, 2005, 12:52:02 PM
What is it and why...
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Bear03 on October 29, 2005, 01:23:38 PM
What is it and why...

Optimum Nutritions 100% whey.  Good blend of proteins, 110 cals, 1 g fat, 2 g carbs, 24 g protein per serving.  Very affordable.  Pretty good taste, my favorite is vanilla.

I think many will agree with me.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: MCat on October 29, 2005, 03:32:30 PM
I dig optimum, and also VP2 vanilla...Good shit
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Blake on October 29, 2005, 07:39:09 PM
Optimum Nutritions 100% whey.  Good blend of proteins, 110 cals, 1 g fat, 2 g carbs, 24 g protein per serving.  Very affordable.  Pretty good taste, my favorite is vanilla.

I think many will agree with me.


Yep, totally agree.  I've tried many protein powders, even trueprotein.com custom blends, but for overall value and a very high quality product, I can't find anything that beats Optimum 100% Whey.  Hell, it's gotten even better now that they came out with the "Gold Standard" stuff.

I also like VP2, but if I use it any other time than pre/post workout, I feel like it's burning a major hole in my wallet.  Depending on where you get it from, if you figure the price per serving for a 10 lb. bag of Optimum 100% Whey, it's probably only going to be around $.30 to $.36 per serving, which is damn cheap IMO.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: DYA on October 29, 2005, 07:49:18 PM
Optimum Nutritions 100% whey.  Good blend of proteins, 110 cals, 1 g fat, 2 g carbs, 24 g protein per serving.  Very affordable. 

It's affordable, but what blend are you referring to, a whey blend? If you want whey, just stick to an isolate.

The best blended protein powders are:
Dorian's Pro Peptide
Muscle Link Pro Fusion
Optimum's Pro Complex
Biotest Low Carb Grow (no egg though)

there's a couple others, but those all taste great and are reputable companies.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Bear03 on October 30, 2005, 08:12:59 AM
It's affordable, but what blend are you referring to, a whey blend? If you want whey, just stick to an isolate.


There's enough Isolate in the Gold Standar Optimum brand to make it worthwhile.  It's a fast-acting protein powder; there's no casein or glycerine or anything like that.  It's not quite as good as 100% isolate, but for at least half the price, it's the best powder out there.     
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: candidate2025 on October 30, 2005, 02:59:27 PM
ive been using "on" for quite some time now...and its the shit bro. cheap. good tasting. mixes well...high protein.    but i havent tried many brands...so there could be better out there
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Carmello on October 30, 2005, 05:24:33 PM
For Night time, Evopro by Cytosport is the best. For a meal replacement, Myoplex deluxe is the best. As far as whey goes, i don't believe in it. They're now making baby formulas with whey, if it was a strong form of protein, i doubt babies would be able to drink it. but if u want to use it, whey concentrate is the best for muscle size. Try pure whey from Prolab. And for bulking, go with Musclemilk. IMO, i think ON's protein sells based on taste and price, and not so much on results.

If u don't care about spending money, then rack up on Beverly International proteins. They're the real deal. Coleman uses them, and alot of other pro's. Don't know why none of them advertise for them. I got great results from Ultimate muscle protein, and Ultra Size. U won't believe the taste! I've heard alot of hype on muscle provider. I'll try it one day n let u know how it matched up, when i can afford it, lol.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: MCat on October 30, 2005, 09:50:50 PM
what about zero carb from VPX.  Anybody got any imput on this shit
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: johnnyx on October 30, 2005, 11:31:44 PM
Supplement Direct Whey Protein Isolate....no flavor, no sweetners, just pure instantized 92% isolate protein..... they have up to date lab assays which makes it nice to know how old and what your getting!!
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: get big AusSiE on October 30, 2005, 11:37:38 PM
i think mass monster by bodyscience is d best nd it works.

it works because its an australian product nd if it didnt work it will be banned
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Sir Duchaine on October 30, 2005, 11:39:23 PM
any that I can get in a 10 - 20kg sack from the wholesaler, thus avoiding paying a premiun to some supplement company owning prick
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: 250Ben250 on October 31, 2005, 12:16:32 PM
Bump to the Optimum Whey Gold Standard.

One good thing to do is search your area for Distribution Co.'s. Most won't sell to the public, but if you get to know someone there they'll usually let you come in and buy for the wholesale/pre mark up price, even when you're buying relatively low volumes comparably.

A friend of mine is up to his ears in those new Muscle Milk N Oats, I think he got them for around half of what you'd pay in the store.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Carmello on October 31, 2005, 03:03:55 PM
seriously, you're all wasting ur time, and money on whey alone. Plenty of studies support the fact that a combination of whey, and casein, or whey and soy yield greater muscle building effects than just whey alone. And yes, even after training because you give your body a sustained release of amino acids through your bloodstream to the muscles. Why do u think u always see, "eat a small meal an hour after ur whey protein post workout shake." It's cause u absorb it like crazy fast, and u don't digest all of it. How can u in an hour? Pay a little more for greater results. Since i've made the switch to the mix, i've had better stregnth, and size gains than i ever did with whey alone. (sounded like a radio advertisement). If u want value, here's the best deal i know of. Syntrax Matrix 5.0 is a 5lbs bag of whey, micellar casein, and other mixed proteins for 30 bucks. Can't beat that, and the taste is great. Get it at bulknutrition.com. Another one, better quality, for just a few bucks more would be Nitrean from atlargenutrition.com. Per serving, it's got a little more protein punch than the Matrix 5.0 stuff per serving. all in all, both are a good value, yeah!
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Blake on October 31, 2005, 03:45:21 PM
seriously, you're all wasting ur time, and money on whey alone. Plenty of studies support the fact that a combination of whey, and casein, or whey and soy yield greater muscle building effects than just whey alone.

I don't believe anyone said that ALL they eat is whey protein.  Again, we're talking about SUPPLEMENTS.


Quote
And yes, even after training because you give your body a sustained release of amino acids through your bloodstream to the muscles. Why do u think u always see, "eat a small meal an hour after ur whey protein post workout shake." It's cause u absorb it like crazy fast, and u don't digest all of it. How can u in an hour? Pay a little more for greater results.


You don't NEED to ingest different types of protein to get a "steady stream of amino acids".  Multiple feedings of whey protein spread throughout the day would do this quite nicely.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Carmello on November 01, 2005, 12:05:42 AM
I don't believe anyone said that ALL they eat is whey protein.  Again, we're talking about SUPPLEMENTS.



You don't NEED to ingest different types of protein to get a "steady stream of amino acids".  Multiple feedings of whey protein spread throughout the day would do this quite nicely.
Ummm, blake is it? Yeah...ok. Anyway, when making an argument about something, make sure u know what u r talking about, or at least have some evidence to support. Never did i say anyone is on an "all whey" diet cause that would just be foolish to assume. My mistake. Guess u r with the elite 1 percenters of this board who think people really go on "all whey diets," as 99% of people here already know food is the dieting staple, not supps.

Second, learn something about protein, and the different types, and how long they r digested for. Only a fool would take whey every hour or 2, if that's what ur getting at with your little "multiple feedings of whey protein" garbage. It get's too be quite expensive doing it that way anyway. I'm sure since ur probably at home all day unemployed, or have rich parents, or whatever your situation is, that u can just go to your little cheap 10lbs bag of whey, and mix up every few hours, or after a real meal if u want to get all technically retarded. I was giving advice to those who obviously have a life, and a brain, and are out on the go. Between meals (again obviously) the best protein is a whey, casein mix, period. There is no room to argue this point junior. U do it the hard way, and i'll do it a better whey son. Understand? or should i break out the crayons?
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: loler on November 01, 2005, 03:18:12 AM
Ummm, blake is it? Yeah...ok. Anyway, when making an argument about something, make sure u know what u r talking about, or at least have some evidence to support. Never did i say anyone is on an "all whey" diet cause that would just be foolish to assume. My mistake. Guess u r with the elite 1 percenters of this board who think people really go on "all whey diets," as 99% of people here already know food is the dieting staple, not supps.

Second, learn something about protein, and the different types, and how long they r digested for. Only a fool would take whey every hour or 2, if that's what ur getting at with your little "multiple feedings of whey protein" garbage. It get's too be quite expensive doing it that way anyway. I'm sure since ur probably at home all day unemployed, or have rich parents, or whatever your situation is, that u can just go to your little cheap 10lbs bag of whey, and mix up every few hours, or after a real meal if u want to get all technically retarded. I was giving advice to those who obviously have a life, and a brain, and are out on the go. Between meals (again obviously) the best protein is a whey, casein mix, period. There is no room to argue this point junior. U do it the hard way, and i'll do it a better whey son. Understand? or should i break out the crayons?

its protein
as long as youre not ingesting cum to fill your protein quota, who gives a fuck
you fucking retard
and learn to spell you bag of dicks
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Aido on November 01, 2005, 04:11:46 AM
As far as whey goes, i don't believe in it. They're now making baby formulas with whey, if it was a strong form of protein, i doubt babies would be able to drink it. but if u want to use it, whey concentrate is the best for muscle size.

Baby foods have been made with whey protein for a long time now.

The reason, whey is easily digested, so the fact that very young children do not have the most powerful digestive enzymes is not a problem. Not too sure what you mean by a "strong form of protein" , but this is the reason why baby foods use whey, easy to digest, which is hardly something to put off bodybuilders.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Borracho on November 01, 2005, 08:27:37 AM
Yeah, the Cookies N Cream kicks ass.

 :-X Worst taste I ever tried. Had to bring it back.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Steeljunky on November 01, 2005, 10:25:06 AM
Optimum Nutritions 100% whey.  Good blend of proteins, 110 cals, 1 g fat, 2 g carbs, 24 g protein per serving.  Very affordable.  Pretty good taste, my favorite is vanilla.

I think many will agree with me.
I agree, mixes easy in a shaker and goes down like water not like others that feel like mortar mix. Choc. mint aint to bad.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Carmello on November 01, 2005, 11:22:41 AM
Aido, good point. Thanks for the intelligent response and not some pointless garbage like the 2 idiots I'm about to address. I meant, more effective for bbers when i said stronger protein. My mistake.

As for loler, u r a retard. Go suck on blake, and get your protein requirements from his whey fortified jizz.

Protein isn't protein IMO. U don't have to like it. I was just trying to help, as studies show a protein powder from multiple sources, preferably fast, and slow digested protein is superior to whey alone. If u want to justify whey being equal, or better do to value, then there's no point in trying to see otherwise. You can't argue with science.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Blake on November 01, 2005, 12:20:34 PM
Ummm, blake is it? Yeah...ok. Anyway, when making an argument about something, make sure u know what u r talking about, or at least have some evidence to support. Never did i say anyone is on an "all whey" diet cause that would just be foolish to assume. My mistake. Guess u r with the elite 1 percenters of this board who think people really go on "all whey diets," as 99% of people here already know food is the dieting staple, not supps.


Sheesh, why the hostility?  YOU'RE the one who said we're "all wasting our time and money buying whey alone".  That's a pointless comment UNLESS THE ONLY PROTEIN YOU'RE CONSUMING EACH DAY IS WHEY.

Quote
Second, learn something about protein, and the different types, and how long they r digested for. Only a fool would take whey every hour or 2, if that's what ur getting at with your little "multiple feedings of whey protein" garbage.


Again, what I posted was in response to YOU saying that one MUST ingest DIFFERENT types of protein to get a "steady stream of amino acids" into the body.


Quote
It get's too be quite expensive doing it that way anyway. I'm sure since ur probably at home all day unemployed, or have rich parents, or whatever your situation is, that u can just go to your little cheap 10lbs bag of whey, and mix up every few hours, or after a real meal if u want to get all technically retarded. I was giving advice to those who obviously have a life, and a brain, and are out on the go. Between meals (again obviously) the best protein is a whey, casein mix, period. There is no room to argue this point junior. U do it the hard way, and i'll do it a better whey son. Understand? or should i break out the crayons?


LOL!   Where did I state that all I consume is whey?  Furthermore, did I suggest to anyone that they go on an "all whey" diet? 
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: loler on November 01, 2005, 01:23:48 PM
Aido, good point. Thanks for the intelligent response and not some pointless garbage like the 2 idiots I'm about to address. I meant, more effective for bbers when i said stronger protein. My mistake.

As for loler, u r a retard. Go suck on blake, and get your protein requirements from his whey fortified jizz.

Protein isn't protein IMO. U don't have to like it. I was just trying to help, as studies show a protein powder from multiple sources, preferably fast, and slow digested protein is superior to whey alone. If u want to justify whey being equal, or better do to value, then there's no point in trying to see otherwise. You can't argue with science.

ever heard of amino acid profile
go look it up
in the meantime i wont give a fuck about 2% better ingestion rate or some shit as long as i get a good amino profile
go choke on a bag of dicks
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: 250Ben250 on November 01, 2005, 02:19:34 PM
For a meal replacement, Myoplex deluxe is the best. 


Worst...advice....ever.. ...

 ::)
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Bear03 on November 01, 2005, 02:39:14 PM
what about zero carb from VPX.  Anybody got any imput on this shit

Great stuff.  One problem.  Damn expensive.

Many of us aren't really in a position to buy three different protein powders for various situations.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Blake on November 01, 2005, 03:10:57 PM
Many of us aren't really in a position to buy three different protein powders for various situations.


Yup.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: bodybuilder821 on November 01, 2005, 03:37:27 PM
Personally, I believe it should be about quality first. Overall the best jug of protein I have ever bought is called "respect" by PRIDE NUTRITION. 47 grams of pure whey isolate, micellar casein and egg albumen. Check out their website at www.pridenutrition.com.. . They don't cut any corners by using whey concentrate or any other inferior fillers. It tasts great too. My girlfriend even likes to drink it, and you know if a women with no interest in the bb/fitness lifestyle is willing to drink protein shakes, they have got to taste good.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: DYA on November 01, 2005, 03:54:28 PM

Yup.

You need a blended protein powder throughout the day (milk,egg, whey).

You need whey only post workout or pre/post workout, preferably an isolate/hydrolosate blend.


you don't 3 different powders, you need your all purpose blend and a post workout formula
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Blake on November 01, 2005, 04:06:09 PM
You need a blended protein powder throughout the day (milk,egg, whey).

Let's assume for a moment that I take a scoop of whey protein every hour during the day.  Do I NEED a blended protein powder in that case?

Quote
You need whey only post workout or pre/post workout, preferably an isolate/hydrolosate blend

So whey is ineffective if I take it any other time of the day ouside of pre/post workout? 

Quote
you don't 3 different powders, you need your all purpose blend and a post workout formula


I NEED an "all purpose blend" and a "post workout formula"?  Um, maybe if ALL you're going to consume every day is protein powder, and thus don't eat meat, drink milk, eat cottege cheese, eggs, etc. and can't have a whey protein shake very often throughout the day.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Negative05 on November 01, 2005, 05:40:13 PM
I hate to be the one to break to this to you Blake....but if you have trouble getting a whey protein shake during you work or school day then you are going to have MAJOR issues getting bigger and stronger.  A protein shake is the fastest and easiet way to get your protein when you don't have much time. 

Ok, enough flaming you hehe.  Go to Wal-Mart and get a bottle with a flip top spout.  You will use this to drink your shake between classes our on breaks at work.  Just put the protein in the cup, add water (water fountain? lol), and shake it up.  Drink.

Now get a thermo lunch box from Wal-mart and 2 ice packs.  Pack your lunch (turkey sandwich on wheat, potato, pasta, oranges, bananas, canned tuna, etc.) and supplements (aminos, glutamine, creatine, vitamins).  Make sure you get one large enough for 3 meals.  Keep this with you pretty much all the time.  Your muscles do not give a shit if you are working or at school or wherever.  They demand food to grow.

Once you do this for about 3 weeks it will become a habit and won't be such a pain in the ass.  It will be like brushing your teeth.

What else? OH!  Stick to full range squats, bench presses, deadlifts and other barbell exercises in the 6 to 8 rep range.  Use decent form and control your weights.  Do not miss too many workouts.

There you go!  Now you have the possibility of growing muscles.  If this is too much then be happy being small and weak. 
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Blake on November 01, 2005, 06:23:44 PM
I hate to be the one to break to this to you Blake....but if you have trouble getting a whey protein shake during you work or school day then you are going to have MAJOR issues getting bigger and stronger.  A protein shake is the fastest and easiet way to get your protein when you don't have much time. 

Ok, enough flaming you hehe.  Go to Wal-Mart and get a bottle with a flip top spout.  You will use this to drink your shake between classes our on breaks at work.  Just put the protein in the cup, add water (water fountain? lol), and shake it up.  Drink.

Now get a thermo lunch box from Wal-mart and 2 ice packs.  Pack your lunch (turkey sandwich on wheat, potato, pasta, oranges, bananas, canned tuna, etc.) and supplements (aminos, glutamine, creatine, vitamins).  Make sure you get one large enough for 3 meals.  Keep this with you pretty much all the time.  Your muscles do not give a shit if you are working or at school or wherever.  They demand food to grow.

Once you do this for about 3 weeks it will become a habit and won't be such a pain in the ass.  It will be like brushing your teeth.

What else? OH!  Stick to full range squats, bench presses, deadlifts and other barbell exercises in the 6 to 8 rep range.  Use decent form and control your weights.  Do not miss too many workouts.

There you go!  Now you have the possibility of growing muscles.  If this is too much then be happy being small and weak. 

ROFL!
I take it you couldn't sense the sarcasm in my previous responses to DYA.  I'm the one saying it's fine to ingest whey protein multiple times a day amongst the other protein sources one consumes.  It's the others like DYA and Carmello that believe you MUST buy a more expensive "blended source" protein powder in order to make teh "massive gains". 

And what's with all the other general "bodybuilding" recommendations included in your post?  I guess you haven't seen any other posts of mine in the steroids, training, or nutrition section.   :)   ;)
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Negative051 on November 01, 2005, 06:52:29 PM
Whoops!  I thought you were being serious.  What do you think of my bodybuilding tips though?  I am all natural, for the moment, muhahaha
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: TheBigAristotle on November 01, 2005, 08:14:19 PM
Respect protein by Pride Nutrition
260 calories
3.5 grams fat
9 grams carbs
47 grams protein

Protein: Blend of CFM Whey Isolate, Micellar Casein,Egg Albumen
-Has EFA's,CLA,Flax
-Digestive Enzymes
-Glutamine,Arginine,Ornithine

Doesn't taste half bad either. But the greatest thing it that I no longer get any gas or bloat, which is the main reason why I like it so much.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Flex 215 on November 02, 2005, 01:15:33 AM
Beside Post-workout, and pre-workout, Whey protein is also excellent in the mornind, when you first wake up. Your body has not had anything all night, and 20-30 grams of fast digesting whey is good to have, before you make your first solid meal for the day.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: chris_mason on November 02, 2005, 04:19:43 AM
Let's assume for a moment that I take a scoop of whey protein every hour during the day.  Do I NEED a blended protein powder in that case?

So whey is ineffective if I take it any other time of the day ouside of pre/post workout? 


I NEED an "all purpose blend" and a "post workout formula"?  Um, maybe if ALL you're going to consume every day is protein powder, and thus don't eat meat, drink milk, eat cottege cheese, eggs, etc. and can't have a whey protein shake very often throughout the day.


a) Different types/fractions of proteins offer different benefits.  This makes the ingestion of a blend a good thing.

b) The slower digesting proteins result in a greater net retention of ingested protein.  That is also a good thing because the whole point of ingesting a supplemental protein product is to increase the amount of protein our body retains on a daily basis.  Whey only products are the LEAST effective in terms of net retention.

c) Different protein products have varying levels of quality.  For instance, what percent protein by weight is the product?  Whey is not whey, and protein is not protein.  There are products on the market that do NOT meet their label claims.  This includes some of the "biggest" brands out there. 


Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Steeljunky on November 02, 2005, 06:02:11 AM
Worst...advice....ever.....

 ::)

I agree, over priced and tastes like crap.
 
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Booze Bot on November 02, 2005, 09:33:28 AM
Without doubt its Nirto Tech, this awesome supplement gives me the protein i need to fill my muslces after super charged workouts, i have put 78 lbs on my bench press just 4 seconds after taking nitro tech and gained 44lbs of rock hard muscle. Did i mention the low low price of just 600 bucks a serving?
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Carmello on November 02, 2005, 10:04:03 AM
a) Different types/fractions of proteins offer different benefits.  This makes the ingestion of a blend a good thing.

b) The slower digesting proteins result in a greater net retention of ingested protein.  That is also a good thing because the whole point of ingesting a supplemental protein product is to increase the amount of protein our body retains on a daily basis.  Whey only products are the LEAST effective in terms of net retention.

c) Different protein products have varying levels of quality.  For instance, what percent protein by weight is the product?  Whey is not whey, and protein is not protein.  There are products on the market that do NOT meet their label claims.  This includes some of the "biggest" brands out there. 


Thank you Chris. a) and b) was all i was trying to let these guys know. So much for trying to help people here. Maybe they'll listen to u.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Blake on November 02, 2005, 11:24:41 AM
a) Different types/fractions of proteins offer different benefits.  This makes the ingestion of a blend a good thing.

b) The slower digesting proteins result in a greater net retention of ingested protein.  That is also a good thing because the whole point of ingesting a supplemental protein product is to increase the amount of protein our body retains on a daily basis.  Whey only products are the LEAST effective in terms of net retention.

c) Different protein products have varying levels of quality.  For instance, what percent protein by weight is the product?  Whey is not whey, and protein is not protein.  There are products on the market that do NOT meet their label claims.  This includes some of the "biggest" brands out there. 


Good post, Chris, and I certainly agree with what you've stated.  Again, the remarks that you quoted were sarcasic.  I was mainly playing devil's advocate in response to other remarks that were posted.  That's why I was capitalizing the word "need".  In talking about supplements (granted you can argue whether or not protein powder is truly a "supplement") nothing is NEEDED IMO. 

Anyhow, I think many of us can agree that the "best" type of protein powder depends largely on what the intended purpose is.  Meal replacement?  Pre/Post workout only?  Pre-bedtime? Etc, etc......  Because obviously a completely hydrolyzed whey will not be the greatest choice for a meal replacement versus a slower digesting blend, for example.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: dawakaman on November 02, 2005, 02:00:24 PM
My personal choise is Matrix 5.0 by syntrax, it's a protein blend, with some added glutamine peptides(though I can't find an indication that states how much peptides per serving).
It's also very sweet, but if that's your thing, i would highly recommend it.
of course ON's whey is a good choise, but as stated in above posts a protein blend is far superior than a whey only product.

Peace
D

P.S.: quit all the insulting and bitching.Arguing is fine, though.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: chris_mason on November 02, 2005, 05:44:05 PM

Good post, Chris, and I certainly agree with what you've stated.  Again, the remarks that you quoted were sarcasic.  I was mainly playing devil's advocate in response to other remarks that were posted.  That's why I was capitalizing the word "need".  In talking about supplements (granted you can argue whether or not protein powder is truly a "supplement") nothing is NEEDED IMO. 

Anyhow, I think many of us can agree that the "best" type of protein powder depends largely on what the intended purpose is.  Meal replacement?  Pre/Post workout only?  Pre-bedtime? Etc, etc......  Because obviously a completely hydrolyzed whey will not be the greatest choice for a meal replacement versus a slower digesting blend, for example.

I firmly believe that a blend of whey, casein, and egg is about as good as it gets for ANY purpose.

I am not saying this to be argumentative, it is simply what I believe based upon what I have learned over the years with respect to protein ingestion. 
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: 250Ben250 on November 02, 2005, 09:22:37 PM
I will say that I've seen evidence (and I believe this as well to some personal effect) that whey alone can have a relatively significant impact on insulin levels. Some say whey alone after workouts is actually more beneficial than whey+ carbs post workout. I don't completely agree with this, but I've never bought into the 2:1 or even 3:1 ratio of carbs to protein in a post workout shake. From my experience with 100% whey, I've found that a post workout shake ratio of 1:2-2.5, carbs to protein is more ideal.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Bear03 on November 09, 2005, 10:59:48 AM
I'm just feeling the need to add this....I just bought, really to sample, a little bit of Optimum's Rocky Road flavored 100% whey.  I shit you not, it tastes exactly like S'mores poptarts.  It is, without a doubt, the best tasting protein powder i have ever had.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: loler on November 09, 2005, 11:48:45 AM
I'm just feeling the need to add this....I just bought, really to sample, a little bit of Optimum's Rocky Road flavored 100% whey.  I shit you not, it tastes exactly like S'mores poptarts.  It is, without a doubt, the best tasting protein powder i have ever had.

How does it compare to double rich choco
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Bear03 on November 10, 2005, 07:12:51 AM
How does it compare to double rich choco

well, given that it's "the best protein powder i have ever tasted" i would say it's better.  If you like that marshmallow flavor, of course.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: tommyguns on November 10, 2005, 07:59:30 AM
My two cents on the best protein is the stuff by Beverly.  They are tough to beat on quality and taste, but I concede that they are more expensive than some of the others.

The Ultimate Muscle Protein is their newest, and it's a protein blend.  The cookies and cream flavor is awesome!  On a lean gain diet, I'll use it, and add some heavy cream for my fat intake.  As I understand it, the heavy cream provides pure fat without any sugar, it makes the stuff taste even better, and it further slows the absorption of the protein into the body, making this ideal for a meal before bedtime.

The Ultra Size from Beverly mixes easier than the UMP, and it's also a blend.  The vanilla tastes great.  One nice thing about the Ultra Size is that it's extremely convenient to use if you don't want to make a shake.  I'll put some in a bowl and slowly mix in some water with a spoon until it forms a pudding consistency.  Add some whipping cream (or flax) and eat it with a spoon while watching TV or at work.  Nice for a change of pace.  You can also add sugar free flavored syrups if you get tired of the same flavors (e.g., Da Vinci syrups).

The Muscle Provider that Beverly makes is their whey product.  It's very low in carbs, and so people usually switch to that when they are in the final 6-8 weeks of contest prep.  I don't think it tastes quite as good, but it's not bad.  I'll usually put that into a blender and add a few frozen strawberries.  With the final weeks of contest prep, the awesome heavy cream is removed, and I'm stuck with flax or fish oil.  Contest prep sucks on so many levels!  MP is also popular as a post-workout shake with a bunch of fast acting carbs (e.g., their Mass Maker product).

$$$ is always an issue, but since protein is the base substrate (w/o gear, at least), if you're gonna blow money on one of your supplements, doing it with your protein source may not be a bad idea.  Having said that, if you can't afford it, buy an affordable protein blend and make sure you're getting about 1-2 grams per pound of lean mass per day.  I shoot for 1.5 g/lb/day.

Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: halinsmm on November 11, 2005, 12:45:01 AM
i prefer isopure. costs about $35 for 3 lbs at vitamin shoppe. tastes really good and has 50g protein per serving
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: loler on November 11, 2005, 02:32:51 AM
well, given that it's "the best protein powder i have ever tasted" i would say it's better.  If you like that marshmallow flavor, of course.

mixed with milk or water?
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Bear03 on November 11, 2005, 08:03:03 AM
mixed with milk or water?


either.  milk is obviously better, but i was really surprised at how damn good it tastes in water too.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Brutal_1 on November 11, 2005, 07:54:47 PM
mixed with milk or water?


water, always.  Why would you mix pre-digested proteins with non pre-digested ::)  ::)
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Carmello on November 11, 2005, 09:10:19 PM
Ok, enough about nighttime protein and post workout and all that. I think the very best protein powder of all time was the first Infusion protein by San. I say the first because they changed the formula so you have to add an extra scoop, and it's WAY too grainy now. You ruined it San! You really blew it now!!!! U couldn't leave well enough alone! The taste and texture were unmatched. The new formula is that of a chicken shit fucken pussy asshole!

HEY San, Thanks alot fuk faces!!
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: loler on November 12, 2005, 04:16:59 AM
water, always.  Why would you mix pre-digested proteins with non pre-digested ::)  ::)

because taste matters
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: GMCtrk on November 12, 2005, 12:34:02 PM
from what I have used

1) nitrowhey extreme by prosource
2) nitrean from ALN
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Blake on November 12, 2005, 02:26:45 PM
because taste matters

Damn straight.   

And what's the big deal about pre-digested combined with non pre-digested?  Suppose it'll make my muscles shrink and make me teh weak!   ;D
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: gmflex on November 13, 2005, 08:49:39 AM
Muscle milk
RTD or powder form
Banana Cream ;D
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Brutal_1 on November 14, 2005, 11:52:37 AM
because taste matters

Taste matters?! ???  Sounds like either you need to find a new hobbie, or you don't compete :o

I wish I had that luxury, but as long as I'm a competitive bodybuilder...I don't eat for taste 8)
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: loler on November 14, 2005, 03:50:22 PM
Taste matters?! ???  Sounds like either you need to find a new hobbie, or you don't compete :o

I wish I had that luxury, but as long as I'm a competitive bodybuilder...I don't eat for taste 8)

wow, you are hardcore
so hardcore
soooo hardcore

i bet i eat broccoli, rice, chicken and peas more than you do
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Bear03 on November 14, 2005, 05:03:14 PM
Taste matters?! ???  Sounds like either you need to find a new hobbie, or you don't compete :o

I wish I had that luxury, but as long as I'm a competitive bodybuilder...I don't eat for taste 8)

that's really a retarded thing to say.  You can do both.  it's not even hard.  you don't become hardcore by hating eating.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Brutal_1 on November 14, 2005, 08:53:27 PM
 you know what else is retarded Bear?  Taking everything you read on a message board seriously ::)

Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Bear03 on November 15, 2005, 07:23:35 AM
you know what else is retarded Bear?  Taking everything you read on a message board seriously ::)



good point, but i am/was not familiar enough with you to read potential sarcasm when i saw it.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: triple_pickle on November 17, 2005, 06:18:40 PM
i did not like the taste of optimum nutrition's cookies n'cream, too sweet, makes you nauseous and you will find cookie particles floating in your drink.

i recently bought protein from dymatize elite, green apple smells like plastic but tastes good, cafe mocha has the best taste i have ever tried.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Bear03 on November 18, 2005, 04:31:41 AM
i did not like the taste of optimum nutrition's cookies n'cream, too sweet, makes you nauseous and you will find cookie particles floating in your drink.


i think you meant to say that it makes YOU nauseated.  I, for one, like it. 
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: loco on November 18, 2005, 06:05:47 AM
Personally, I believe it should be about quality first. Overall the best jug of protein I have ever bought is called "respect" by PRIDE NUTRITION. 47 grams of pure whey isolate, micellar casein and egg albumen. Check out their website at www.pridenutrition.com.. . They don't cut any corners by using whey concentrate or any other inferior fillers. It tasts great too. My girlfriend even likes to drink it, and you know if a women with no interest in the bb/fitness lifestyle is willing to drink protein shakes, they have got to taste good.

I checked this out and it does look like a great product, but $54.95 plus shipping, for 2.5 lbs?  Have they lost their minds?

I'll stick to Labrada Pro V-60.  It's high quality, tastes great, mixes easily and I get 3 lbs for only $25.99 at www.DPSNutrition.com.  Pro V-60 is a blend of Whey Concentrate, Whey Isolate, Casein and Egg Albumin. 
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: 250Ben250 on November 18, 2005, 02:31:43 PM
I just found a new favorite ----

Dymatize 100% Iso whey. Its all 100% WPI, nothing else, mixes pretty thin, even with a shaker bottle. Its the best tasting I've had by far, a little more cocoa-like vs. a fake chocolate taste. 25gms protein per scoop, no carbs, no fat.

I found 5 lbs for $40 at my local store. Not a bad deal at all.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: triple_pickle on November 21, 2005, 08:22:57 AM
< I found 5 lbs for $40 at my local store. Not a bad deal at all.

i bought mine for $26 @ http://www.wholesalesupplementstore.com/eliteberryblast5lb.html
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: Jr. Yates on November 21, 2005, 10:57:52 AM
i use sndcanada  or pacific nutrition both canadian but good prices.
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: 250Ben250 on November 21, 2005, 01:51:17 PM
< I found 5 lbs for $40 at my local store. Not a bad deal at all.

i bought mine for $26 @ http://www.wholesalesupplementstore.com/eliteberryblast5lb.html


You're talking about a different product. Yours is a blend, whey concentrate, isolate, etc. The new Dymatize isowhey is 100% whey isolate.

http://www.wholesalesupplementstore.com/dymatize-iso100.html

^ this is the 2 lb version for $30, I got 5lbs for $40.  :)
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: bigjay80 on November 21, 2005, 02:44:06 PM
MHP's Probolic-SR:  The cookies 'n cream tastes great and it is a great blend...plus the added EFA's don't hurt either!
Title: Re: best overall protein powder
Post by: the_Hater on November 29, 2005, 08:03:52 AM
OPTIMUM NUTRITION 100% WHEY.

THE ONLY PROTEIN POWDER I DONT SHIT IN THE MINUTE.

And it works, tastes good (chocolate or vanilla are my fav).

Very cheap.