I posted the exact same thing as the OP months ago but i guess no-one notices me.
2006 was a very close one, i thought that was a fair decision to Jay. Lets be honest, Chad Nicholls said it was close, and he is as biased as anyone towards whoever he helps (which is what exactly?) so going on that you could say Jay won.
2007 was Wolf. Then Victor/Dex then Ronnie/Jay. At least i don't have to sit at home watching this garbage anymore, after that decision i'm not wasting time on the O again.