In the fifties Muscle Beach became the place to be for many bodybuilders. You know the scene. Muscleheads living near the beach and not wanting to work so what do many do? Use their bodies to make money.
So if you were seen in those quasi gay magazines such as Adonis, etc., posing nude or in a G-string you could kiss goodbye to ever winning the AAU Mr America title.
Along comes Joe Weider to the rescue and he has his own Mr America title. The great Sergio Oliva could place only 4th in the AAU....of course he won Most Muscular Man! Sergio insisted on entering the IFBB Mr America contest because he wanted that title. He won it on the same day he won the IFBB Mr Universe. Larry Scott also never competed in the AAU Mr America. That title wasn't a strictly bodybuilding contest and more of a muscle pageant. I can tell you back in 1959-60 there was a lot of controversy when Harry was awarded Mr America.