Look at the results from 1959. Harry probably not in the top 6 or 8. Art Harris was probably the best but was given Most Muscular. Hapless Ray Routledge had to wait two years to win the title.
George Orlando was featured in Weider mags so not a favourite in the AAU. Strange judging in those days.
1959 Mr America - AAU
1 Harry Johnson
2 Ray Routledge
3 Pete Ganios
4 George Orlando
5 Vern Weaver
6 Elmo Santiago
7 Lloyd Lerille
8 Art Harris
9 Kenny Hall
10 Fred Schutz
11 Hossein Shokouh
12 Buddy Basil
13 Walt Cuzzimano
14 Tommy Johnson
15 Leo Downes
16 Joseph Simon
17 Bill March
18 Mike Ferraro
19 Hank Wayne
20 George Wojnowski
21 Harry Lanehart
22 Gene Wells
23 Sam Martin
24 Ed Jacobs
25 William Crozier
26 Pat Hensley
27 Lowell Scott
28 Joe Marino (1)
Most Muscular
1 Art Harris
2 George Orlando