How much longer can he be overlooked now?
Thing is, he looks really great standing by himself. But put him next to the top 5 and he's still got a bit more mass and symmetry to go. He's good - and I'm a fan of his - but he's not top 5 material just yet. It's easy to judge in pictures, but when you watch video or even better in person you can see the real differences between these guys.
As for Victor Martinez - someone posted that one arm is bigger than the other and that he looks rediculous. It's so slight it's not even noticeable, unless you want to point out subtle flaws like that. For that matter, Jay Cutler's entire right side at the olympia was larger than his left - upper AND lower body - but everyone seemed to miss that.
Speaking of Jay - which I'm surprised noone posted - here's a comparison for you:
Jay, looking great... before: (circa 1998)


Waaaay after. And Waaay older looking.