Should Heisman be stripped? - Bush Reportedly Got Over $100K From Agents

[Earl1972]

yes it should be stripped

vince young proved he was the superior player anyways so give it to him he earned it

E

[Dos Equis]

Not.

[Al-Gebra]

h8r

[Mr. Intenseone]

yes it should be stripped

vince young proved he was the superior player anyways so give it to him he earned it

E

Dammit Earl, sometimes when i agree with you, you have to go and scwer up your post by saying something stupid like "Vince young was the superior player" !!

[Earl1972]

Dammit Earl, sometimes when i agree with you, you have to go and scwer up your post by saying something stupid like "Vince young was the superior player" !!

who dominated the most important game of the season and who got greedy trying to make a highlight reel play that cost his team the ball and in the end the game?

E

[Mr. Intenseone]

who dominated the most important game of the season and who got greedy trying to make a highlight reel play that cost his team the ball and in the end the game?

E

One game doesn't earn you the Heisman..........who won the NFL rookie of the week last week???

[Dos Equis]

One game doesn't earn you the Heisman

Thank you.  Bush was the most explosive, dominant, and talented player in college football last year.  Running, receiving, punt returns, kickoff returns.  He did it all.  Didn't he have over 300 all purpose yards in one game?  I think he averaged something like 9 yards a carry?  Not even close.

[Al-Gebra]

Just remembered that Auburn ran the table in 2004, but didn't get a shot at the nat'l championship . . .

[Earl1972]

One game doesn't earn you the Heisman..........who won the NFL rookie of the week last week???

we're talking college football here so the nfl is irrelevant

that one game happened to be the national championship and vince's numbers wouldv'e been far greater but he never played the whole game

E

[Mr. Intenseone]

but he never played the whole game

E

All the more reason why he didn't get it!

[Earl1972]

All the more reason why he didn't get it!

yeah probably vince would mow down teams by halftime and would be taken out

he could've scored 10 td's in alot of those games

E

[Dos Equis]

yeah probably vince would mow down teams by halftime and would be taken out

he could've scored 10 td's in alot of those games

E

And Bush was splitting carries with LenDale White. 

[Earl1972]

And Bush was splitting carries with LenDale White. 

agianst weak competition

not to mention vince dominated the rose bowl and bush lost his team the game

E

[Dos Equis]

agianst weak competition

not to mention vince dominated the rose bowl and bush lost his team the game

E

You mean all those players from the PAC 10 who get drafted every year?  There really isn't much difference between the PAC 10 and the Big 12 IMO. 

Earl stop drinking the hateraide.    

[Al-Gebra]

yeah probably vince would mow down teams by halftime and would be taken out

he could've scored 10 td's in alot of those games

E

 

clearly never watched a big 12 game in his life.

[Earl1972]

You mean all those players from the PAC 10 who get drafted every year?  There really isn't much difference between the PAC 10 and the Big 12 IMO. 

Earl stop drinking the hateraide.    

all those pac 10 players play for USC

not hating, i just think that vince was a better college player and reggie should lose the heisman for breaking the rules

E

[Earl1972]

clearly never watched a big 12 game in his life.

over the l;ast 5 years what pac 10 teams other than usc are on the same level as texas and oklahoma?

also remember vince beat ohio state who killed notre dame

a team that reggie had to cheat to beat by pushing leinart in the end zone

once a cheat always a cheat give the heisman to vince

E

[Dos Equis]

all those pac 10 players play for USC

not hating, i just think that vince was a better college player and reggie should lose the heisman for breaking the rules

E

Nah.  The Pac 10 puts a lot of players in the NFL every year.  So does the Big 12.  I've never done a comparison, but I doubt there is a huge disparity for either conference. 

I think it is debatable whether Vince was a better college player than Bush.  I personally think it's Bush hands down, but I can see an argument for Vince.  His game against USC was one of the most dominant college performances I've ever seen. 

[Al-Gebra]

I have Big 12 loyalties, but to be fair . . . I think the Pac-10 puts out a lot of players of NFL caliber . . .wer're talking about freaking california as a recruiting base.

Um, and since Earl doesn't seem to watch college football, Oregon just beat Oklahmoma. 

[Al-Gebra]

HAHAHAHAHAHA!!!! Earl's team just got PWN3D by Reggie Williams.  Where did Reggie Williams play college ball, Earl?

[Earl1972]

I have Big 12 loyalties, but to be fair . . . I think the Pac-10 puts out a lot of players of NFL caliber . . .wer're talking about freaking california as a recruiting base.

Um, and since Earl doesn't seem to watch college football, Oregon just beat Oklahmoma. 

I said over the last 5 years and the refs for that game have been suspended for screwing over oklahoma

alot of those cali players play in the sec and big 12

E

[Earl1972]

HAHAHAHAHAHA!!!! Earl's team just got PWN3D by Reggie Williams.  Where did Reggie Williams play college ball, Earl?

he played at washington and he played far from great we held them without a td

E

[Al-Gebra]

the refs for that game have been suspended for screwing over oklahoma

those mofos really did screw OU over. bastards. but then again they were always w/in striking distance.