Phil does look great, but this is bodybuilding… if I say the Jets have a horrible run defense it doesn’t mean I don’t like the Jets, fuck I bleed gang green… but they can stop the run…
Similarly, Phil is narrow and has an obviously high chest, both of these flaws/ qualities will certainly limit his growth and potential
Again this is bodybuilding, it’s a physique competition, to say “phil looks great” is a great compliment but worthless in when comparing him to other dudes…