Now I get why your handle is Mr Magoo. LOL!!
i think jay looked better in 2001 than 2006. deal. i think he was cursed by ronnie coleman to not win his title at his best, but rather when ronnie was at his worst. the two sadly did not coincide. the same situation would have happened if, say, levrone took it in 2002. levrone was way off his best but would have won.
i should have rephrased that jay is the only one whose olympia win didn't happen at his own peak, but then you'd again LOL at me and make me write this out anyway.