I don't think gordiano is really showing any of the symptoms of that actually.
If a person gets tired walking up a flight of stairs, why should they be considered an athlete?
What is your definition of athlete then?
Why is it necessary to argue semantics to such an extreme with "sport" and "athlete?" Would you prefer that "guy" or "people who compete" or some other pseudonym be used in place of athlete every single time a reference to bodybuilding is made?
Why is it only truth if it's brutally negative? If this Jay Cutler is a nice man, why would saying such be ass kissing? If he isn't an "athlete" why must it be said in such a hateful way?
Andy why is it when the latter is done it is covered by the guise of "I'm just being true?"