Lately I've been buying Skippy Natural PB.
Unlike Smucker's this PB has the same taste, texture, etc. of regular PB.
In fact, I don't quite know what the difference is between it and regular.
I compared the label on Skippy Natural to a jar of Jif, and they're essentially identical (within 1g here and there).
Skippy's price isn't bad either. When on sale, I've gotten them for as low as $1/jar.
Where's Princess?
She's the resident expert on Peanut Butter.