i just had 2 post when i saw all of these STUPID POSTS u people don't know anything about football! oh by the way Peyton is the best QB in football and has been for the past several years and now he won the superbowl, because of his historic comeback against the patriots...its not up for debate unless your a fucking idiot(which many of Peyton critics r) yea he should quit playing football and take huge amounts of steroids to fill out his 6-05 frame to make u idoits happy- oh and give up the MILLIONS of dollars hes making. i met he sits up at night thinking about what a bunch of losers think of him while playing on the internet for hours every night cause they have no life. mom get me some more chezzy puffs i have more posts to read! sweet! beefcake beefcake!!!
You mean the best qb this year? D Brees led the leauge in passing in 2006 and Brady did in 2005. Culpepper did in 2004. What exactly did Manning do in the playoffs last year? How about the previous five years before that? When has he ever had anything less then pro bowl receivers to throw to? Does throwing to hall of fame/probowl receivers have anything to do with his regular season stats? When they are fazed out by good teams in the playoffs his stats are straight up terrible. Still trying to figure out how the best QB ever throws 3 td's and 7 picks in his best playoff showing to date. Also trying to figure out how the best QB ever cannot score a single offensive point, and the kicker has to kick ALL the points in the game (ravens game). Manning is a fantastic regular season QB, and one of the greatest ever. What you said is inaccurate imo You could say he was the best ALL AROUND qb this year, but the playoff failures over the last 6 do not allow him that title. The last 6 years of failure in the playoffs are not wiped clean because he succeeded one time in the seven years of trying. Does life work that way? Your kid has all the best tutors and fails 7th grade 6 times, but on the seventh passes so you throw them a party saying they are the smartest kid ever? Manning is a great QB, honestly he is. But what adversity has he been through? When has he not had pro bowl/hall of fame players catching the ball? Hell edge was running it for him up until last year. When has he not been in some of the nfls most explosive and weapon ridden offenses? What adversity has Manning ever been through? Receivers leaving? His most trusted players/friends leaving the team (in there prime)? Injury? Injury riddden team? Coaches who where with him his whole career leaving, what?
I am not saying Manning is not fantastic regular season qb. But you do not just wipe away 6 years of playoff failure becuase his team won a sb this year. He got it done and he deserved to win. But that does not change the fact his playoff stats once again stunk this year. He is a liabilty to his team in the playoffs 80 percent of the time based on the stats over the last 7 years (including this year).
StatsBrady 12 - 2
< Career postseason recordManning 7 - 6
Brady - 3 rings , 2 sb mvp
< Superbowl wins/sb mvpsManning - 1 ring, 1 sb mvp
Brady - 3
< Afc championship titlesManning - 1
Brady 80 -25
< Total career winsManning 92 - 52
Brady (3 in 4 years)
< Superbowl streaksManning (1 in 1 year)
Brady 20 - 9
< postseason td / int ratioManning 18 -16
Brady 88%
< Career postseason ratingManning 81%
Brady (0)
< number of pro bowl /hall of fame recievers Manning (3)
Brady (3)
< sets of different recievers over careerManning (1)
