If you negotiated his contract you would be aware of the content and contractual obligations? You were happy for Silvio to sign the contract but immediately went out and posted photographs on your site which was in breach of that contract? If you considered the clause to be unfair or unreasonable, why did you have Silvio sign it?
If as you say, you did act as a manager for Silvio I would suggest that you either learn more about the legal function and requirements of a contract or at the very least advise them to have a lawyer look over it.
If you brokered the contract you would be the one to know if photographs appearing on Silvio's site breached it? Why ask anyone else not party to it's content?
I have LONG HISTORY with Weider/AMI group...since 1991!!!
My gym is official gym for FLEX magazine photoshoots for about 6 years...
Editor of the magazines is someone whom I consider a friend and I always had PERFECT RELATIONSHIP in true sense of that word.
He knows how passionate I can be about bodybuilding and WHAT I REALLY DO for the athletes...He, for change, has RIGHT opinion about me.
In the beginning - when Chris Lund started shooting in my gym - I couldn't help but take some shots at the same time...and WHEN HE TOLD ME TO STOP - IT HAVE NEVER HAPPENED AGAIN...
I don't even get tempted and therefore don't even go on the gym floor...as I would be like the kid in the candy store and take not one but thousands of photos of top IFBB pros in contest shape...
One word from Peter Mc Gough - WOULD BE ENOUGH...
However, Peter NEVER responded to my Email IF what Robin is telling me - is INDEED A PROBLEM...
I have been taking photos for YEARS...AND IT WAS NEVER PROBLEM...EVER....until Silvio told me that he got the call from Robin...
As Robin didn't call me - I made sure to call him and asked him: "what's up?"...
After he expresses "exclusivity" issues...etc I reminded him that I am not the MD...or other competing publication...I am Milos Sarcev - possibly "longest" contracted Weider athlete - loyal to Weider and the IFBB for 15 years...and I have been doing the same [posting photos of NUMEROUS WEIDER ATHLETES without having the problem - year after year...I talked about that already - but th ebest example would be - training photos of Ronnie 3 weeks out from 2006 Mr. O...followed by SPECTACULAR posing photos of Jay - 2 weeks out...]
My photos are also used in Weider publications from time to time (making me some kind of FLEX photographer if you really want to think about it...on top of everything else)...
In LONG conversation with Robin I kept giving him many scenarios where I could "work around the contract if need be" - just to be "politically correct"...
Simplest one (which I mentioned repeatedly: I could have Silvio's moderator post the photo on his site first...and 2 seconds later I could copy that same photo and put on my site...here on getbig...etc)
So, WHO ARE WE KIDDING?
There was NEVER a problem...until Shawn created it (as miserable "low life" can't do anything productive or good...and this kind of things just fuel him and excite him - as he loves putting other people in trouble and enjoys watching it...).
He involved both Robin and Bob - and that's how we got ourselves a problem...What's worst Shawn did that in the worst possible time for Silvio - right before stepping on the stage - which is just unbelievable to me...
Shawn wanted to separate me and Silvio...and Silvio fall for it...
Something was created out of nothing ...breach of contract was NOT the issue...but sure "sounds good"...
And that is after I did everything for Weider/AMI to secure publication contract with Silvio as his manager at the time who made sure Silvio goes with AMI instead of MD...as Steve Blechman was calling for Silvio like his house was on fire...
After bringing Silvio personally to Weider office and making sure he would do photos even less than a week away from the contest (something that competitors really don't want to do)...etc..etc...
I always have THE BEST interest for the athletes...Weider organization...and the IFBB...and somehow for some people it appears exactly the opposite

.