Melvin Anthony - ROBBED of at least 2 positions

[kilojoule]

I think thats the best i have ever see Melvin, his routine was the best of the night, and every time he hit a pose, he was flawless, perfect and by far the most balanced physic, same goes for Dexter,

[G o a t b o y]

I think thats the best i have ever see Melvin, his routine was the best of the night, and every time he hit a pose, he was flawless, perfect and by far the most balanced physic, same goes for Dexter,

He was only robbed of 1 position.  He beat Ronnie, but he didn't beat Wolf.

[dearth]

more like he robbed 2 positions.

he had never have the conditioning to be a "top tier" pro

[kilojoule]

a toss up between Melvin and Dexter for 3rd if you ask me, and though it seems Dexter has him on calves structure ect, there was something special about Melvin last night, he really has a flowing flawless body

aside topic, Gunther is the worst bodybuilding commentator ever, worse then glass, who seemed to think everyone was a contender for the title, But Gunther was talking absolute dribble out of his anus, he contributed nothing intelligent for the night, just kept speaking of his 5th place finish,

what a ####

[kilojoule]

more like he robbed 2 positions.

he had never have the conditioning to be a "top tier" pro

Uummmm like Jay,

yeah his conditioning was "top tier" alright, 

[tweeter]

Melvin was better than Ronnie, Jay, and possibly Victor (his fake synthol calves ruin his physique for me); Dex and Wolfe were better and should have been top 2

[MAXX]

He was only robbed of 1 position.  He beat Ronnie, but he didn't beat Wolf.

agreed

[Archer77]

Anthony is one of my personal favorites and in a fair world he deserved to place much higher.  I think Rockell also belongs on the list of bodybuilders who received screwy placings.

[dearth]

Uummmm like Jay,

yeah his conditioning was "top tier" alright, 

conditioning
Jay > Melvin

& Jay had a little more "momentum" than smooth Melvin

[NarcissisticDeity]

Mevlin was soft he looked very good though ! his placing is on the money Wolf should have beat Ronnie and Victor could have traded places with Jay that would have been fine by me , but it could have gone either way.

[Dballn247]

Melvin looked really good and place, I think he could have swapped positions with Ronnie Coleman.  Someone in a thread a week ago was trying to tell me that Ronnie Rockell was just as good if not better than Melvin...

[Bluto]

wasnt melvin one of the jackson five dancing brothers on the show?

if so he should be penalized and disqualified.

[realkarateblackbelt]

Melvin has perfect symmetry, balance, aesthetics. He hits every pose right, and he's not small.
I had him 3rd.