Hey... i take offence to your 150 pound stick comment
lmao
i must admit, you are one of the exceptions, but you have small joints and a small frame. jj is a stockier frame and, although he is nowhere near contest shape (or perhaps his best shape), nothing wrong with being a solid 175+ if he so desires.
being in shape is subjective. many consider the contest ready bber shape (or not far off) to be too extreme and they have a point eg. benaziza, muntzer, etc.
for physique contest purposes though, the guy is too fat and yes, with the 'spilled over' comment, it would imply/indicate that he has the delusional perma bulker disease.
people, if you can't see your abs 4 weeks out, don't enter bbing comp.