okay, it would be cool IF=
-the graphics were ultra detailed while in the gym, and you really worked out. like every rep, every set, every bodypart. but to lift couldnt be something lame like "tap x for bicep contraction), it would need to be something to do with timing or speed or rythem between two buttons.
-you earned money at first just by like robbinig people and shit..this is how you could buy food and supplements. you actually buy supplements, cook food, and administor injections(once you get far enough, built enough, and have enough money to afford the steroids); maybe in fact you have to place in a "natural" show before you can unlock STEROIDS,..like upon recieving your medal they show a short clip of some mafia looking guido buff guy walking you over to the trunk of his car and showing you his stash and saying "its time to move up to the big time, little fella"..soemthing like that. maybe you could sell steroids at first to get your moneys up.
-you progress in the game by doing shows and wining competitions. you can do good by getting endorsed by supplment companies and by getting cover shoots. starting out with small companies..then working your way to the top. im sure the top honor would be a muscletech sponsorship...they would probably be the ones making the game anyways. "muscletech= Olympia bound" or something like that as a title..
- of course...you would get to have very detailed sex with fitness sluts.
..........lol.........
just soem ideas. im bored.