Which one of the guys I listed is super inconsistant? Any NFL gm would take every single one of those players over Vick. Vick is a world class athlete, and a great rusher, but he is a very poor qb, and to small to be a rb in the NFL.
im not arguing thir consistancy in ;evel of play...just in their entertainment level.
i guess if you are super educated when it comes to playing skills and and nfl talent, then the better the player=the more entertaining
but, most people, myself included, have no idea if a player has got real SKILL or not..its all about the glamourous plays, the long bombs, the juke moves, and the big hits.
who is really going to notice a defensive linemans technique when he does a swim move on the center

lol.. very few people