Dorian Yates at his best VS Ronnie Coleman at his best : who would win?

[NarcissisticDeity]

yawn, I already refuted this. You're so desparate that you've resorted to regurgitating old arguments.

no, you haven't shown me anything. All you've done is make a claim without any evidence to back it up.

lmfao the audacity of YOU claiming someone who is regurgitatinng old arguments most ironic statement

I don't have to show you , I have NO desire to show you , your opinion is worthless to me you've proven yourself consistently ignorant about competitive bodybuilding you bore me and evidence is YOU claiming Yates is flat out wrong when he said he had better conditioning than Ronnie Coleman , despite the guy being an IFBB judge

see hypocrite , see me laugh at your ignorance

[QuakerOats]

use this pic instead lol

hahahaa, or this one.

[NarcissisticDeity]

hahahaa, or this one.

or this one a view most Coleman fans are used to

[NeoSeminole]

lmfao the audacity of YOU claiming someone who is regurgitatinng old arguments most ironic statement

lmfao the audacity of YOU saying irony when you've been using the same old arguments longer than anyone else on Getbig.

I don't have to show you , I have NO desire to show you , your opinion is worthless to me you've proven yourself consistently ignorant about competitive bodybuilding you bore me and evidence is YOU claiming Yates is flat out wrong when he said he had better conditioning than Ronnie Coleman , despite the guy being an IFBB judge

yawn, come back when you have something intelligent to say. You have been proven wrong over and over in this discussion. Your logic is flawed and your reading comprehension leaves much to be desired. Your opinion is no more important than a pile of dog shit yet you claim guys like Joe Weider, Peter McGough, Shawn Perine, Greg Meritt, and Lonnie Teper are all wrong. So spare me your lame retort that I'm ignorant about bodybuilding when it's you who doesn't know what the f*ck he's talking about.

[chaos]

You're all cokksuckers.

[NeoSeminole]

hahahaa, or this one.

ND fantasizes about this pic of Dorian chasing after him and rolling around in the sand.

[Victor VonDoom]

Ronnie.  Bah!

[m8]

or this one a view most Coleman fans are used to

[NarcissisticDeity]

lmfao the audacity of YOU saying irony when you've been using the same old arguments longer than anyone else on Getbig.

yawn, come back when you have something intelligent to say. You have been proven wrong over and over in this discussion. Your logic is flawed and your reading comprehension leaves much to be desired. Your opinion is no more important than a pile of dog shit yet you claim guys like Joe Weider, Peter McGough, Shawn Perine, Greg Meritt, and Lonnie Teper are all wrong. So spare me your lame retort that I'm ignorant about bodybuilding when it's you who doesn't know what the f*ck he's talking about.

lmfao the audacity of YOU saying irony when you've been using the same old arguments longer than anyone else on Getbig.

same old arguments? my argument is consistent and why? because I always knew what I was talking about , that's the difference between you and I  how can you form an argument when you didn't even know how contests were judged? I'll tell you , you can't. you didn't even know that balance & proportion were separate entities , you didn't know all rounds are physique rounds until I thought you  its YOU who had to amend your ' argument ' constantly not I.

yawn, come back when you have something intelligent to say. You have been proven wrong over and over in this discussion. Your logic is flawed and your reading comprehension leaves much to be desired. Your opinion is no more important than a pile of dog shit yet you claim guys like Joe Weider, Peter McGough, Shawn Perine, Greg Meritt, and Lonnie Teper are all wrong. So spare me your lame retort that I'm ignorant about bodybuilding when it's you who doesn't know what the f*ck he's talking about.

I always laugh at your frustration level , and come back when I have something ' intelligent ' to say ? lol

ND fantasizes about this pic of Dorian chasing after him and rolling around in the sand. wow this was profound lmao

You've NEVER ever once proven me wrong , on the contrary my ignorant little friend , its YOU who has been constantly corrected , corrected about who is drier & harder , corrected about balance & proportion , corrected on how contests are judged , corrected about Ronnie & Dorian's all-time best showings , I mean I could go through the laundry list but you get the idea. and the best parts is you're among the biggest hypocrite on this board because YOU many times have dismissed the opinions of Peter McGough , Dorian Yates , Ronnie Coleman , Lee Priest , Bev Francis , Roger Schwabb , etc and I never dismissed anyone's opinion , I always stated it was their opinion and NOT a fact , especially considered they do not judge contests  and the people who do judge contests you have dismissed 

when it comes to competitive bodybuilding I hands down know more than you , Hulkster , pumpster , iceman , all combined ! my argument has been consistent its used with the IFBB judging criteria in mind and its backed up with judges' quotes that specifically compared the two , as usual you can't counter my argument and never could , so run along now boy-Neo your novelty has worn off again , perhaps when I'm feeling more charitable I'll entertain and correct more of your nonsense.

[England_1]

ND's determination and domination is simply LEGENDARY. He has never once been proven incorrect on this forum. It's absolutely comic how easily he owns suckster, semen, et al.



The thickness of Dorian's lats here as an olympia ROOKIE is incredible. What did Ronnie do his at his 1st olympia?

[Hulkster]

dorian couldnt' come close:

top to bottom

just look at those quads, the lats, etc

[johnny]

....................

[MONSTER_TRICEPS]

Ronnie Yates.

[NeoSeminole]

same old arguments? my argument is consistent and why? because I always knew what I was talking about , that's the difference between you and I how can you form an argument when you didn't even know how contests were judged? I'll tell you , you can't. you didn't even know that balance & proportion were separate entities , you didn't know all rounds are physique rounds until I thought you its YOU who had to amend your ' argument ' constantly not I.

ha ha ha, you don't know what you're talking about. That's why this discussion has been going on for over 2 yrs. How can you claim to be more knowledgeable about bodybuilding when I've corrected you on numerous occasions such as the difference between conditioning, definition and density, balance and proportion, symmetry, and the importance of shape and fullness. Also, your opinions are in opposition with the best authorities on the matter (e.g. Dorian has the best back ever and would beat Ronnie at their respective primes). I guess you know more than Joe Weider, Peter McGough, Shawn Perine, Greg Meritt, and Lonnie Teper?

[m8]

....................

Unbeatable.

[Barracuda]

Shouldn't this stuff be confined to the truce thread?

[m8]

Shouldn't this stuff be confined to the truce thread?

Well it's better than the Dorian vs Nasser non-sense.

[m8]

Amazing.

[Barracuda]

Well it's better than the Dorian vs Nasser non-sense.

I noticed that crappy debate has started again. 

[NarcissisticDeity]

ha ha ha, you don't know what you're talking about. That's why this discussion has been going on for over 2 yrs. How can you claim to be more knowledgeable about bodybuilding when I've corrected you on numerous occasions such as the difference between conditioning, definition and density, balance and proportion, symmetry, and the importance of shape and fullness. Also, your opinions are in opposition with the best authorities on the matter (e.g. Dorian has the best back ever and would beat Ronnie at their respective primes). I guess you know more than Joe Weider, Peter McGough, Shawn Perine, Greg Meritt, and Lonnie Teper?

Again Neo you're full of shit period you never corrected me on ANY points , you'd have to know what you're talking about in order to do so , and you're very ignorant to this day about competitive bodybuilding , you can't correct someone when you don't and didn't even know how contests were judged , what consists of great conditioning , that balance & proportion are two separate and distinct entities , that all rounds are physique rounds , which year is a particular bodybuilders peak , etc , etc , etc

you're a pretender who tried to impress me with his resume and fell flat on your face and again the irony of YOU saying I guess I know more than , Joe Weider , Peter McGough , etc , etc when YOU dismissed a hell of a lot more people , you're a hypocrite and an ignorant one at that

my argument is rock solid and hasn't budged its right on the money and try as you may NONE of you guys can counter it , just deny it .

Neo's novelty = worn off ...bye . bye boy-Neo run along and try and impress someone else with your certified personal trainer degree and your extensive ' knowledge ' of competitive bodybuilding lmao

[NarcissisticDeity]

ND's determination and domination is simply LEGENDARY. He has never once been proven incorrect on this forum. It's absolutely comic how easily he owns suckster, semen, et al.



The thickness of Dorian's lats here as an olympia ROOKIE is incredible. What did Ronnie do his at his 1st olympia?

You're a smart man and right on the money.

[jaejonna]

damn muscletime.com for unleashing unseen pics of Ronnie and Yates..

[NarcissisticDeity]

dorian couldnt' come close:

top to bottom

just look at those quads, the lats, etc

He actually looks awesome in this shot but alas this is Dorian's pose and no one can touch him in it

and I laughed when you typed top to bottom lol he would need a pair of proportionate calves you know as well as I do calves are judged in this shot as much as any mother muscle , Ronnie's calves are getting dwarfed buy his enormous quads an increase as little as 10 pounds from one year to the next can throw off one's balance & proportion , the you have to factor in all his other structual flaws compared to Dorian such a torso length , upper & lower body balance , proportion of the forearms in relation to the biceps and triceps , the sweep of the lats , and see all rounds are physique rounds you have to factor in muscular bulk , density & dryness , posing & presentation , completeness from head to toe and its clear Dorian beats Ronnie in this pose , this is a pose Ronnie has a lot of advantages in but never seems to look great in like Lee Haney did or Dorian Yates

and another laughable point is when you typed Dorian couldn't come close , I mean this is one of Dorian's many poses . on the contrary Ronnie has to come close to Dorian in this shot and this particular one he actually does come close to a point and then Dorian's shot is just more complete and meets ALL of the criteria better

[NeoSeminole]

Again Neo you're full of shit period you never corrected me on ANY points , you'd have to know what you're talking about in order to do so , and you're very ignorant to this day about competitive bodybuilding , you can't correct someone when you don't and didn't even know how contests were judged , what consists of great conditioning , that balance & proportion are two separate and distinct entities , that all rounds are physique rounds , which year is a particular bodybuilders peak , etc , etc , etc

Again ND you're full of shit period you never corrected me on ANY points , you'd have to know what you're talking about in order to do so , and you're very ignorant to this day about competitive bodybuilding , you can't correct someone when you didn't know the difference between conditioning, definition and density, balance and proportion, symmetry, and the importance of shape and fullness.

you're a pretender who tried to impress me with his resume and fell flat on your face and again the irony of YOU saying I guess I know more than , Joe Weider , Peter McGough , etc , etc when YOU dismissed a hell of a lot more people , you're a hypocrite and an ignorant one at that

ha ha ha, you haven't even posted that many quotes from different people. I've posted 30+ quotes which you dismissed all of them. So it's impossible for me to dismiss more people than you. Nice try, kiddo.

my argument is rock solid and hasn't budged its right on the money and try as you may NONE of you guys can counter it , just deny it.

that's why Joe Weider, Team Flex, and Lonnie Teper all disagree with you?

you have much to learn, little boy. Run along now and come back when you actually have something intelligent to say.

[NarcissisticDeity]

Again ND you're full of shit period you never corrected me on ANY points , you'd have to know what you're talking about in order to do so , and you're very ignorant to this day about competitive bodybuilding , you can't correct someone when you didn't know the difference between conditioning, definition and density, balance and proportion, symmetry, and the importance of shape and fullness.

ha ha ha, you haven't even posted that many quotes from different people. I've posted 30+ quotes which you dismissed all of them. So it's impossible for me to dismiss more people than you. Nice try, kiddo.

that's why Joe Weider, Team Flex, and Lonnie Teper all disagree with you?

you have much to learn, little boy. Run along now and come back when you actually have something intelligent to say.

Yeah I thought so NO CONTENT as usual thanks for proving my point  have a nice day