Dorian Yates at his best VS Ronnie Coleman at his best : who would win?

[Earl1972]

Still waiting for you to post that quote from me 

you said you thought dorian lost in 97

THAT MEANS YOU DISAGREE WITH THE PERFECT SCORE HE GOT

E

[NarcissisticDeity]

yes and he looks much smaller in the contest pics

on stage is where it counts, besides ronnie still owns those pics

E

Because he is smaller in contest pics duh and where he's at his best is where it counts and you're like Hulkster just make blanket statements lol Ronnie owns nothing

[Hulkster]

I never once said the judges got it wrong that's a lie

I won the truce thread which is why I stopped posting in it  which is exactly why YOU follow ME like a lost puppy from thread to thread

Quiting while you're ahead is NOT the same as quiting  

you do realize I am going to pull up a million quotes where you have said this?

me, neo, iceman etc all know you have stated this many times in the past.

many times.

[Earl1972]

Because he is smaller in contest pics duh and where he's at his best is where it counts and you're like Hulkster just make blanket statements lol Ronnie owns nothing

all that counts is what you see on stage and if you want to bring gym pics into the argument ronnie still wins

either way dorian looks like shit and you would NEVER want to look like him

E

[NarcissisticDeity]

you said you thought dorian lost in 97

THAT MEANS YOU DISAGREE WITH THE PERFECT SCORE HE GOT

E

Again I never said ' the judges got it wrong ' that's a lie

I don't think he should have won that year but in no way shape or form do I think it was fixed

[NarcissisticDeity]

you do realize I am going to pull up a million quotes where you have said this?

me, neo, iceman etc all know you have stated this many times in the past.

many times.

Show me ONCE where I ever claimed ' the judges got it wrong '  I said I personally don't think Dorian should have won , big difference

[Hulkster]

Again I never said ' the judges got it wrong ' that's a lie

I don't think he should have won that year but in no way shape or form do I think it was fixed

hello?

saying that you don't think dorian should have won in 97 is the same thing as saying that you think that the judges got it wrong because they had him win it that year..

 

holy shit you are dumb..

[Earl1972]

Again I never said ' the judges got it wrong ' that's a lie

I don't think he should have won that year but in no way shape or form do I think it was fixed

i never said anything about a fix

if you think a different guy should've won then who the judges picked, THAT MEANS YOU FEEL THE JUDGES GOT IT WRONG

you are starting to give "suckmymuscle" a run for his money in the lack of common sense department

E

[NarcissisticDeity]

hello?

saying that you don't think dorian should have won in 97 is the same thing as saying that you think that the judges got it wrong because they had him win it that year..

 

holy shit you are dumb..

No it isn't

[Earl1972]

Show me ONCE where I ever claimed ' the judges got it wrong '  I said I personally don't think Dorian should have won , big difference

you've resorted to playing dumb just to defend your argument

E

[NarcissisticDeity]

i never said anything about a fix

if you think a different guy should've won then who the judges picked, THAT MEANS YOU FEEL THE JUDGES GOT IT WRONG

you are starting to give "suckmymuscle" a run for his money in the lack of common sense department

E

Let me explain this to you , I don't think Dorian should have won but I don't think Nasser beat him  

[NarcissisticDeity]

you've resorted to playing dumb just to defend your argument

E

NO you resorted to making stuff up , again. don't speak for me or misquote me

[Hulkster]

HypocriticDeity is breaking his own records on being stupid...

 

he doesn't understand that disagreeing with the outcome of a contest is the same as disagreeing with the judges..

 

[Earl1972]

Let me explain this to you , I don't think Dorian should have won but I don't think Nasser beat him  

fine

dorian won so that means you think SOMEBODY deserved to be in first place and you feel the judges got both 1st and 2nd place wrong

E

[Hulkster]

Let me explain this to you , I don't think Dorian should have won but I don't think Nasser beat him  

so who should have won the contest in your opinion then?

shawn ray?

Kevin?

answer.

[Earl1972]

HypocriticDeity is breaking his own records on being stupid...

 

he doesn't understand that disagreeing with the outcome of a contest is the same as disagreeing with the judges..

 

he has lost all credibility

seriously

E

[Hulkster]

he has lost all credibility

seriously

E

no, the last of that died back here:

http://www.getbig.com/boards/index.php?topic=230546.0

[NarcissisticDeity]

HypocriticDeity is breaking his own records on being stupid...

 

he doesn't understand that disagreeing with the outcome of a contest is the same as disagreeing with the judges..

 

No I can disagree with the judges , I just don't think what Dorian showed in 1997 is what a Mr Olympia should be , you have to hand it to the judges they were consistent , I don't think a Mr Olympia should win with a torn bicep , tricep , quad , Dorian even at his worse in 1994 looked pretty good in 1997 he looked awful but in some poses he looked great so while I can understand why he won I just don't think he should have and again I don't think Nasser beat him , he should have came closer but beat him no

[NarcissisticDeity]

no, the last of that died back here:

http://www.getbig.com/boards/index.php?topic=230546.0

epic hypocrisy this coming from the guy who has posted more photoshopped pics than ANYONE on GetBig lol

[Hulkster]

you have to hand it to the judges they were consistent

that is a very bad thing considering the way dorian looked post tear.

not a good thing..

they consistently overlooked the massive flaws, torn muscles, growing gut and lack of detail to give him 'perfect' scores anyway..

 

[NarcissisticDeity]

that is a very bad thing considering the way dorian looked post tear.

not a good thing..

they consistently overlooked the massive flaws, torn muscles, growing gut and lack of detail to give him 'perfect' scores anyway..

 

Well to echo the judges sentiments Yates bicep tear made NO overall difference , and you don't know how contests are judges hence why you don't know how he could get perfect scores

[Hulkster]

Well to echo the judges sentiments Yates bicep tear made NO overall difference , and you don't know how contests are judges hence why you don't know how he could get perfect scores

fuck how can you agree with that statement?

it really shows how LITTLE you know about the sport:

[Earl1972]

fuck how can you agree with that statement?

it really shows how LITTLE you know about the sport:

imagine being new to the sport and seeing that this monstrosity is considered the pinnacle of bodybuilding

no wonder the sport didn't grow

E

[NarcissisticDeity]

fuck how can you agree with that statement?

it really shows how LITTLE you know about the sport:

94/95/96 MADE NO overall difference and Hulkster I said the torn bicep made NO overall difference NOT a torn bicep and tricep  please pat attention to the debate

and you're the guy who claimed Ronnie has more detailed calves than Dorian if I know little about the sport than YOU know absolutely NOTHING 

[NarcissisticDeity]

he has lost all credibility

seriously

E

yeah thats what they've been claiming for years now , at least I had some ' credibility ' to loose  you guys would need to know how the game is played before having any lol