Jay Cutler Vs Dorian Yates (both at their best)

[Earl1972]

hahahaha, yes this guy was known for his awesome conditioning.

sick

in a disgusting way

E

[Big_Tymer]

hahahaha, yes this guy was known for his awesome conditioning.

look at that gut hanging over the front of his shorts

[Ragnarok]

Insane argument.  Scary to think that so many people think Jay could be superior to Dorian.....
 

[MRMD2003]

Jay's 2001 form was impressive !!!!! However, Yates 93 form was superior !!!!!! When dorian turns around, the show is over !!!!! The only back the that is equal to or better then Yates is Coleman

[QuakerOats]

Jay's 2001 form was impressive !!!!! However, Yates 93 form was superior !!!!!! When dorian turns around, the show is over !!!!! The only back the that is equal to or better then Yates is Coleman

same old "back" bullshit, Yates had ONE THING on Jay, back thickness, that's it, his back isn't as wide as Jay's and Jay beats him EVERYWHERE else.

[MRMD2003]

Quaker,

             Jay had better quad's, hams . and calves then Dorian ?   

[tbombz]

[m8]

Hi Candizzle.

[tbombz]

yo !


jay clearly outmasses dorian.

however dorian is much drier and better conditionied than jay ever was.

jay has arms and hamstrings.

dorian has a midsection.

its pretty close...

[TrueGrit]

jay clearly outmasses dorian.

however dorian is much drier and better conditionied than jay ever was.

 I agree. To me, Dorian is just more impressive overall.. All the clichés about grainy, granite hardness ring true.

[johnny1]

you sir... are an idiot..

It's asking about at their best... not how many years they are at their best...





























By the way, Jay beat Dorian

LOL for someone with 5662 posts...and you are calling me an idoit?...Point was dorian in any year he was @ the top would beat Jay with his superiour condationing alone, so......if jays best was 2001 (considered by many to be his best) vs Dorian in 1993 (0r 95) dorian would come out on top...BY THE WAY JAY DIDNOT BEAT DORIAN hope that helps

[johnny1]

Dorian's back at its peak smokes Jay's.

Tiny...

Yip thats a great shot of Arnolds legs there...quiet a rare one alright... theres a couple more floating around of Arnold @ the 74 0 on those high angles where his quads are big....surely your not suggesting Arnolds legs were "better" than Dorian Yates are you?

[GoneAway]

Yip thats a great shot of Arnolds legs there...quiet a rare one alright... theres a couple more floating around of Arnold @ the 74 0 on those high angles where his quads are big....surely your not suggesting Arnolds legs were "better" than Dorian Yates are you?

I was replying to your statement that Arnold had some of the smallest quads of any Mr. Olympia.

[Relentless]

At their best?  Jay, actually. 

[England_1]

Jay does not outmass Dorian. Look what happens when he tries to get ripped. He can only come in around 250-255lbs. 2001 was the only time Jay ever had ripped glutes and he was about 250lbs. Also, consider the fact that size alone doesn't win anything. Jay outweighed Dexter by probably 40lbs this year yet still lost decisively to him. Dorian would simply destroy Jay. End of story.

[England_1]

Jay could never match this physique, not in a million years. Dorian is simply flawless.

[RC Money]

Jay could never match this physique, not in a million years. Dorian is simply flawless.

Look at Kevins right arm

has to be like 2-3inches bigger.

[England_1]

Kevin's arm was nothing more than soft inflammed tissue. Like we all know, you all hate Dorian so much that you'll point out the tiniest little thing to degrade him  You all fear Dorian at his best.

[johnny1]

I was replying to your statement that Arnold had some of the smallest quads of any Mr. Olympia.

one of the Smallest in terms of upper/lower body balance, lower quads, hamstrings in particaluar were out of balance with massive pecs,arms etc..not the best pic or year of arnold to post, however its a fairly rare one of Arnold at the 80 O.

[RC Money]

Kevin's arm was nothing more than soft inflammed tissue. Like we all know, you all hate Dorian so much that you'll point out the tiniest little thing to degrade him  You all fear Dorian at his best.

I didnt say anything negative about Yates, i was just impressed at Kevins arm cause Dorians certainly wasent small and Kevins still looks huge.
I am not hating, you are nut hugging.

[NeoSeminole]

Jay at his best was pretty damn good. It would be a battle of front vs. back

[GoneAway]

one of the Smallest in terms of upper/lower body balance, lower quads, hamstrings in particaluar were out of balance with massive pecs,arms etc..not the best pic or year of arnold to post, however its a fairly rare one of Arnold at the 80 O.

I agree, his hamstrings in side shots were often a little weak when compared to his quads. That 1980 Mr. Olympia shot is very rare, thanks for posting it.

Here's a somewhat rare shot taken by Christine Zane at a guestposing exhibition in 1971. Arnold's entire legs were massive, and even his hamstrings were in good proportion.

[RC Money]

Jay at his best was pretty damn good. It would be a battle of front vs. back

WOW

[The_Hammer]

People saying Jay is bigger than Dorian are wrong.  At prejuding of this years Olympia Jay weighed 265 lbs and then lost 12 lbs overnight for the finals. He still looked 5 or 6 weeks out compared to Yates during the finals.  Yates from '93 is bigger, not to mention when Dorian ballooned up to the 260-270's and still out conditions Cutler.

Jay is better from the front than Dorian, but from the back Dorian completely blows Jay away from head to toe.  Dorian beat guys like Shawn Ray, Flex Wheeler, Nasser, Levrone, Ronnie Coleman, Labrada, ect who all looked much better than Jay from the front.

[suckmymuscle]

Jay at his best was pretty damn good. It would be a battle of front vs. back

  Wrong - as usual. The only pose Jay wins is the front double biceps. Dorian wins the other two front mandatories, the side triceps and also the back mandatories on account of superior conditioning. The side chest is debatable, but I still give it to Yates on account of superior balance.

SUCKMYMUSCLE