I'm with Billy on this one.
First off... How the fuck can someone judge squat depth from the front? I'm seriosly getting sick and tired of the internet bullshit about judging when the only evidence shown is crappy shakey videos from a completely different angle of what the judges are seeing. I did a screen capture of the low point of Donnie's 3rd attempt at home last night. I'll post it this evening (Youtube is blocked by my work server, so I can't repeat the image and I didn't upload it). From that image, I think its pretty damned close---as close as what a front judge could possibly say with their perspective. You have to judge depth from the side, not the front to be accurate. Not only that, at the lowest point of that attempt there is no way in hell you can judge depth if you tried, because his belly/the belt obscures the top point of thigh. The best you can say is its close.
Theres no way to see shit with the bench on this video clip because the damend video is jumping around like its got Mexican beans up its ass. I got seasick watching the bench attempt
I will say the deadlift is open for interpretation. Donnie is a big, bowelegged, SHW lifter, just like i am. Depending on the angle, my legs don't necessarily look "locked" at the top of a deadlift when I know damned good and well they are. If I weighed 180 lbs, it'd be a completely different issue with the appearance. The rules say "complete extension" not "hyperextension". And again, that camera angle isnt' from a 90 degree to the side perspective, so it gives a different appearance. He did get his shoulders back.
The one issue I've got with all of it is at the completion of the deadlift, that bar descended damned fast. My undestading is the bar should be lowered "under control". This means if you are dropping the bar, follow that thing do the ground with your hands around it so it looks like you've got it. Again the video jumped all over the place, but it looked like he didn't follow the bar fast enough to the ground and it left his grip. Its really hard to tell from the video posted.
The other bottom line is Donnie is the first to total this much. No matter how deep he went in his squat, no mattter how clean his bench was, and no matter how smooth and locked the deadlift was, I'm willing to bet there will be dozens of online critics bitching about his lifts. Thats really the bottom line. His total was approved by qualified judges, its been done. I'd much rather see someone man the fuck up and lift more than all of this online bitching. Thats the real way to deal with the controversy. Mike millers squat was a prime example. No one really gives a shit anymore about that squat. Its a has been record now. The same thing needs to be done with these lifts instead of bitching about them. Man the fuck up and solve the problem by beating Donnies total.