I agree Vics quads aren't as detailed as they should be. The surgeon did a great job in the reattachement/re-placement but I think the leg needs a bit more time to develop the muscle detail again, if he can.
However, Vics shape is much better than Kai's. Its just genetic. Kai wins on quads for sure and wins on conditioning. Vic's upper body is much better than Kai's. Kai is definitely blocky and has a fair shoulder to waist ratio. Overall I give Vic the nod.
Freeman didn't get good comparisons.