Fair point about being out-classed. I just think, much as you wouldn't like to believe it, Dorian would out-class 2003 Ronnie, but Ronnie would still 'win' as you put it. You can argue Jay won 2001 show, but basically it didn't happen. And Ronnie 2003 was a whole lot bigger with better condition. Your point about the mandatories is strong, but Dorian wouldn't win on a single bodypart, this would be his downfall.
FYI contests aren't judged on bodyparts , you're showing your ignorance again contests are judged on the criteria ALL of the criteria , what you don't know is all rounds are physique rounds , which means the judges look for ALL of the criteria in every single round , ever wonder how Dorian won the symmetry round despite not being the most symmetrical? or the posing round despite not being the best poser? all rounds are physique rounds is your answer
This is where Dorian would beat Ronnie , he simply accumulates more mandatory poses and seeing the judges look for ALL the criteria in ever single pose this clearly favor's Yates , so while Ronnie may have better parts in a pose he doesn't have meet ALL of the criteria better , judges look for balance & proportion in every single pose , as well as density & dryness , as well as muscular bulk as well as posing & presentation , so while Ronnie may have advantages in part of this criteria Dorian has more advantages in ALL of this criteria
What separates Dorian any year is balance & proportion and density & dryness these are areas Dorian will always have a clear advantage compared to any year Ronnie , depending on the year Ronnie has an advantages in muscular bulk however that's negated by a deficiency in conditioning & balance , another clear advantage for Yates is posing & presentation , Dorian is clearly better at posing and posing to show his physique off to it's best advantage
Ronnie 2001 may come very close to equaling Dorian in density & dryness but falls short in muscular bulk , balance & proportion , posing & presentation , etc this is how it works Dorian simply meets ALL of the criteria better than Ronnie and this is exactly how he would win because this is judged in every single pose in every single round , so please learn how contests are judged before you try and say why Ronnie would win then you would spare yourself the embarrassment of claiming Dorian wouldn't win a single body part especially when it's not how contests are judged
