Gynocomastia - this should be many points deducted, never a 1st place awarded.
All competitors should be placed higher that don't have it visible, those who do, slot drop.
Strange mid section- Abs should be lean, tight, even and like bricks or squares 6-8 visible.
Deduct points when this is not in check with others on stage. Pregnant belly syndrome.
Boils, Pimples, and other skin problems- horrible, ugly and flat gross. Damn Take a shower with soap.
Deduct more points for being a big dirty pill popper.....do not award 1st place.
Visible Lumps from Synthol or other- see above.
Torn bodyparts- These are visible when analyzing the complete look. Judge correctly take away points.
Again take away points for all torn muscles don't award a torn bodypart with a first place trophy.
Uneven bodyparts- take away points when one side is not the same size as the other.
Puffy, Bloated, Watery- deduct alot of points, period. Lean, Shredded, Ripped, Hard, Dry, Cut....all good.
Implants- Very hard to prove...deduct points and have proof, no 1st place trophy. Pec implant???
Being judged honestly at the time of prejudging and not giving special points to the current incumbent from the previous year........This is flat out sick, its like the incumbent already has a 25% lead going in.
This leaves symmetry, muscularity, posing, and the weight to height factors to include for points after deducting the above.
Didn't include tattoos, hair loss, an ugly ass face or bad mouthing the judges or IFBB media... those are non-factors. Very Large Tatts should be considered if it covers a muscle and its not visible to judge.
Striated triceps, chest, lower lats, outer thighs, hamstrings, obliques... all deserve more points.
If you look at this list and judge your favorite BB, you may want to reconsider he is the best ever.