The problem with Shawn and Francis is that they were very short. Like it or not, stature effects aesthetics.
Paris and Reeves not only had the bodies, they had the height. They win.
1. Reeves
2. Zane Shorter, but too complete to be ignored. And it's not like he is Ray, Labrada, or M. Anthony short. All three of these guys lie about their height. Frank goes about 5' 9", maybe a wee bit more.
3. Paris