Who is the better BB all time - Nasser vs Dorian ?

[ag2]

Discuss

[Pecs]

  why is this even a thread???

[NarcissisticDeity]

Discuss

At his worse Dorian was better than Nasser at near his best 

[delta9mda]

6-0 mr olympia wins

15 of 17 shows entered = 1st place, the 2 others were 2nd place.

Yates owns the 90's.

[NarcissisticDeity]

6-0 mr olympia wins

15 of 17 shows entered = 1st place, the 2 others were 2nd place.

Yates owns the 90's.

only two people beat him as a pro that's mind boggling that record stands ALONE to this day

[suckmymuscle]

  Dorian remains to this day the only bodybuilder under 6'3 to weight a genuine 280+ lbs. All other bodybuilders under that height who stepped onstage at 280+ lbs - Fux, Nasser, Harrison, Coleman - had far less than optimum conditioning. Dorian was ripped and dry to the bone at 283 lbs.

SUCKMYMUSCLE

[johnny1]

Discuss

Not sure if your asking a legitimate question or you want to have yet another thread of pointless arguing with everyone about their favorites, whatever the case may be, Dorian was the better bodybuilder while Nasser had certain bodyparts that were better than Dorian's

[m8]

Dorian, no comparison.

[dyslexic]

Who is the better bodybuilder of all time?

[NeoSeminole]

Dorian remains to this day the only bodybuilder under 6'3 to weight a genuine 280+ lbs. All other bodybuilders under that height who stepped onstage at 280+ lbs - Fux, Nasser, Harrison, Coleman - had far less than optimum conditioning. Dorian was ripped and dry to the bone at 283 lbs.

uhh, no. If Dorian was ripped and dry to the bone at 283 lbs, then he would have competed at that weight.

[suckmymuscle]

uhh, no. If Dorian was ripped and dry to the bone at 283 lbs, then he would have competed at that weight.

  He was more ripped than Ronnie at the 2003 Olympia, yes, but not as dry as he liked to be be. Furthermore, remember that Dorian usually overdieted and lost more muscle than fat and water in the last few weeks before a show.

SUCKMYMUSCLE

[NarcissisticDeity]

uhh, no. If Dorian was ripped and dry to the bone at 283 lbs, then he would have competed at that weight.

That's like saying he in 93 if he could compete at 269 pounds he would have

The main thing was, I was really still learning how to prepare for a contest and I made a point of recording everything I did and also took pictures every week going into the show (the 1993 Mr. Olympia). What I realized is that for '92 I was in great shape but I was near enough in that shape five or six weeks before the contest and kept coming down in bodyweight, wanting to get harder.

What I realized was happening was that I was just about as hard as I was going to get anyway. And if you are losing more weight at that point, what are you losing? I came to the conclusion that I was losing muscle. Although I was big and shredded in '92, I was competing well below my potential so, with that knowledge and all of my records, I decided the following year I would try to avoid that, basically the over dieting.

he could have competing at 280+ if he wanted but unlike Ronnie it was never about packing on as much size as he could it was always about the total package . he would have been as ripped & dry at that weight as he was at 257? probably not but still better conditioned than Ronnie

[Hedgehog]

why is this even a thread???

Because it's never been discussed before.

Hope this "heps".

And FWIW, I think Frank Zane outclasses both of them.

However, if I were to pick one I'd say Dozzer.

He had a back, you know.

[Rome]

Huh? What is the debate? I think Nasser was great but only Lee , Arnold and Ronnie out Sandow Dorian.
Really not a contest, sorry. 

[tstmaniac]

Yates for sure

[delta9mda]

only two people beat him as a pro that's mind boggling that record stands ALONE to this day

yes and those 2 people are either dead or way retired.

[jaejonna]

 

[Nasty Nate]

Because it's never been discussed before.

Hope this "heps".

And FWIW, I think Frank Zane outclasses both of them.

However, if I were to pick one I'd say Dozzer.

He had a back, you know.

Frank Zane weighed as much as a 10th grader.

[D_1000]

I am not a homo, so I will have to go with Dorian.

[mwbbuilder]

Stupid marketing campaign to live off the real success of other bodybuilders.

Hey, let's put up a thread of Nasser versus some great bodybuilder.

Like there is really some debate.

Nasser and friends: True champions just let their accomplishments speak for themselves.

Not use a bunch of their nuthuggers to implant suggestions in the minds of who he calls pumpkinheads.

Give it a rest Nasser. No one cares. Your career is over. Move on with life. Get those nuthuggers to stop embarrassing you.

[tendonitis]

so I guess you won't be buying a pair of Nasser's soiled manties anytime soon

[dov]

Stupid marketing campaign to live off the real success of other bodybuilders.

Hey, let's put up a thread of Nasser versus some great bodybuilder.

Like there is really some debate.

Nasser and friends: True champions just let their accomplishments speak for themselves.

Not use a bunch of their nuthuggers to implant suggestions in the minds of who he calls pumpkinheads.

Give it a rest Nasser. No one cares. Your career is over. Move on with life. Get those nuthuggers to stop embarrassing you.

Looks as though you just started, yet, ANOTHER Nasser thread

[ManBearPig...]

so I guess you won't be buying a pair of Nasser's soiled manties anytime soon

i got an awesome pair of shitstained ones.  you can borrow them when i'm done wearing them on my face for a week.  No better feeling than a HUGE Nasser shit stain on your face.

[El Diablo Blanco]

Who is better?  The three time uncrowned Mr. Olympia or some schmoe named mwbbuilder that posts on getbig?

Discuss?

As a bonus who gets more $$$ for their soiled posing trunks?

[mwbbuilder]

Looks as though you just started, yet, ANOTHER Nasser thread

Yes. Just to them know how stupid their plan is and we don't see Nasser versus Arnold, or Cutler, or Labrada, or Bannout, or Scott, or Reeves, or whoever the other classy bodybuilding champions they plan to link him to  next.