People can say what ever they like about Jay. Dorian and everybody else from the late 90ies early 00ies would look like chickens beside him 
Jay looked great--it is a HUGE overstatement to say he would make Dorian or Ronnie look like a chicken (afterall, he stood next to Ronnie and got dwarfed on more than one occassion).
Notice Dorian's symmetry here.....almost as good as the photoshopped pics of Jay. Don't get me wrong, Jay kicked ass this year and I am thrilled for him.