for the most part no guy is out of any womans league. in the movie "ghosts of girlfriends past" the dead uncle tells his nephew that "an ugly chick is fucked. she will never get any decent looking guy no matter what. but an ugly dude is just fine, because any guy can be cool, regardless of what he looks like. and cool is attractive."
moral of the story, dont put her on the pedestal, at least not unless she is doing the same to you.