not really looking for answers. I already know why 01 ASC Ronnie would beat 93 and 95 Mr. Olympia Dorian.
just trying to understand your reasoning since it contradicts the opinion of bodybuilding experts.
Peter McGough and Shawn Perine both acknowledge that a 10 lbs heavier Dorian wouldn't beat 01 ASC Ronnie. They make it explicitly clear the only version that could touch Ronnie would be his 93 pre-contest form, which outweighs Ronnie by 20 lbs. Why do you think that is?
anyone with a brain can see your claim about Dorian having better conditioning and balance is wrong b/c if this were true, then Dorian wouldn't need to outweigh Ronnie by 20 lbs in order to compete. It doesn't make sense that a bodybuilder with better conditioning and balance would ALSO need to carry 20 lbs more to touch 01 ASC Ronnie.
so either Peter McGough and Shawn Perine are both wrong (which discredits anything they say) or you're wrong (far more likely).
not really looking for answers. I already know why 01 ASC Ronnie would beat 93 and 95 Mr. Olympia Dorian.
no you don't that's speculation on your part nothing more
just trying to understand your reasoning since it contradicts the opinion of bodybuilding experts.
Peter McGough and Shawn Perine both acknowledge that a 10 lbs heavier Dorian wouldn't beat 01 ASC Ronnie. They make it explicitly clear the only version that could touch Ronnie would be his 93 pre-contest form, which outweighs Ronnie by 20 lbs. Why do you think that is?
They never once claimed he wouldn't beat him that's you once again coming to your own conclusions and what's ironic about your posts is you flat out denied McGough as an expert but now he is when it suits your purposes ? hypocrite much kid?
Another expert who you dismissed ( Dorian ) said if he were to compete against Ronnie he would choose his 1995 Olympia showing lets not forget that expert
the experts agree Dorian has the edge in conditioning & balance , what's left? posing , presentation and muscular bulk against a 247 pound Ronnie , seeing you're fond of drawing conclusions I'll let you draw who has the advantage in those
anyone with a brain can see your claim about Dorian having better conditioning and balance is wrong b/c if this were true, then Dorian wouldn't need to outweigh Ronnie by 20 lbs in order to compete. It doesn't make sense that a bodybuilder with better conditioning and balance would ALSO need to carry 20 lbs more to touch 01 ASC Ronnie.
so either Peter McGough and Shawn Perine are both wrong (which discredits anything they say) or you're wrong (far more likely).
Dorian doesn't need to outweigh Ronnie to beat him , Dorian Yates who is an IFBB judge said specific to the topic he is better balanced & better conditioned than Ronnie but you don't want to talk about that , you're to busy trying to create anything , McGough has said Dorian's conditioning is better than Ronnie , Kevin Horton said Dorian's conditioning is unmatched to this day I mean you and Hulkster are in denial
You're so desperate for anything you're looking for any angle to discredit the experts and pass your opinion off as fact , you're exposed as ignorant , biased and stupid
Dorian said he would choose 1995 does that mean he's right and McGough & Perine and wrong? NO it's an opinion on a subjective topic , you're trying to pass off opinions on a subjective topic as right or wrong more weak logic on your behalf , desperation is leading you to commit to weak positions
I think Ronnie 2001/2003 would give Dorian a fuck-of-a-run for his money 1993/1995/93 precontest but ultimately Dorian has advantages in balance & proportion , density & dryness , posing & presentation and muscular bulk ( depending on the year )