Personally, of the two, I find Carmella more attractive. I've always been attracted to that sleepy eyed look that she has. Naomi, well, she's rumored to be so cracked-out, and that's the main reason she quit the porn business.
I would nail the fuck out of Carmella and Naomi, but if either of them were HIV+ and I knew it, of course I would have to decline, jimmy hat or not!!!