Ronnie Coleman vs Dorian Yates

[bodybuilder1234]

I see this fantasy match-up hasn't really been discussed on these forums.
Personally I'd go with Dorian because he beat Ronnie every time they fought on the stage, only battle scars left on Dorian only show his place in history.
Who wins this and why?

[ShipSekki]

I see this fantasy match-up hasn't really been discussed on these forums.
Personally I'd go with Dorian because he beat Ronnie every time they fought on the stage, only battle scars left on Dorian only show his place in history.
Who wins this and why?

 Dorian is overrated.

 Ugly thick midsection and fucked up arms.

[dyslexic]

They are almost the same age and Ronnie still looks like a brick house. Dorian on the other hand looks like a pissant personal trainer...


wait...


that's not what I meant.

[Wiggs]

I see this fantasy match-up hasn't really been discussed on these forums.
Personally I'd go with Dorian because he beat Ronnie every time they fought on the stage, only battle scars left on Dorian only show his place in history.
Who wins this and why?

I love how you dorian fucks always go to the "the beat Ronnie every time they fought on the stage" No shit!  This is also when Ronnie looked like ass (for Ronnie) this is akin to saying if Jordan played 1 on 1 vs Kobe in 94.  Well in 96. Well Jordan was in his prime and Kobe was 16 and his skill was no where near what it is now.  Doesn't seem like a very fair comparision does it?  It's the same thing with bodybuilding.  You take their best and put it against each other not that BS that BS logic you Dorian dicklickers use.
Dorian best = 93 O  Coleman best = 01 Arnold or 03 Mr. O. 

BTW Coleman wins... 03 O destroys anything ever brought to a bodybuilding stage.

[Hulkster]

Personally I'd go with Dorian because he beat Ronnie every time they fought on the stage

so did everyone else. ronnie lost to everyone back then all the time.

could they have beat ronnie at his peak? hell no.

same with dorian.

[dr.chimps]

Dorian is overrated.

 Ugly thick midsection and fucked up arms.

HugeNasser.Com---> GetbigTeam Nasser --->

[Hulkotron]

HugeRipped dwarfs them both.

[beefcakeblake]

I see this fantasy match-up hasn't really been discussed on these forums.
Personally I'd go with Dorian because he beat Ronnie every time they fought on the stage, only battle scars left on Dorian only show his place in history.
Who wins this and why?

why did you make another one, we were fine with the first one.

[Hulkster]

no no. the first one is too short.

[MCWAY]

I love how you dorian fucks always go to the "the beat Ronnie every time they fought on the stage" No shit!  This is also when Ronnie looked like ass (for Ronnie) this is akin to saying if Jordan played 1 on 1 vs Kobe in 94.  Well in 96. Well Jordan was in his prime and Kobe was 16 and his skill was no where near what it is now.  Doesn't seem like a very fair comparision does it?  It's the same thing with bodybuilding.  You take their best and put it against each other not that BS that BS logic you Dorian dicklickers use.
Dorian best = 93 O  Coleman best = 01 Arnold or 03 Mr. O. 

BTW Coleman wins... 03 O destroys anything ever brought to a bodybuilding stage.

Interestingly enough, the same Yates fans that point out that tend to get testy when you mention Yates' loss to Haney in 1991.

[beefcakeblake]

Interestingly enough, the same Yates fans that point out that tend to get testy when you mention Yates' loss to Haney in 1991.

well some dorian fans don't bring that up at all and just wanna debate them at their best

91 man haney looked crazy there derserved it 100%

does any one notice in like 91 a little in 92, maybe 93, dorians mid section looked really weird kinda like a keg.
maybe it was just me it ruined his 91 form for me.

imo 95 dorian king yates>>>>> ronnie no flex coleman

[Sir Bigness]

Totally different Builds!!

[mesmorph78]

Nd in 3....2....1

[~UN_$ung~]

the fanboys are all so great, hulkster, earl, team nasshole, nd..............they are completely bereft of any objectivity


like in that picture hulkster posted above.............he went out of his way to find ronnie's most impressive front lat spread pic of all time, and compare it with dorians worst front lat spread pic of all time


these guys are unreal






as much as i like dorian, you gotta admit that he would have a very hard time with a prime-ronnie coleman.......but these guys lack any objectivity

[delta9mda]

the fanboys are all so great, hulkster, earl, team nasshole, nd..............they are completely bereft of any objectivity


like in that picture hulkster posted above.............he went out of his way to find ronnie's most impressive front lat spread pic of all time, and compare it with dorians worst front lat spread pic of all time


these guys are unreal






as much as i like dorian, you gotta admit that he would have a very hard time with a prime-ronnie coleman.......but these guys lack any objectivity

why does ronnies torso look flat, not 3d as Yates? que hulkster in 5, 4, 3, 2........

[affeman]

case closed

[FREAKgeek]

I see this fantasy match-up hasn't really been discussed on these forums.

You know, I too am surprised this has never been discussed. 

[Hulkster]

and compare it with dorians worst front lat spread pic of all time

LOL so a perfectly clear shot of dorian at similar distance from the stage to the ronnie shot at dorian's self proclaimed best ever shape in 1995 is his 'worst front lat spread shot of all time?'

 

typical nuthuggers. dorian's best can't measure up so they all of a sudden claim its his worst..

 

this story is getting old nuthuggers.

[Hulkster]

its one thing to prefer dorian.

but to take a great shot of dorian at his best ever shape and proclaim it to be the worst shot ever simply because ronnie was better is a little bit sad and pathetic.

[Shockwave]

its one thing to prefer dorian.

but to take a great shot of dorian at his best ever shape and proclaim it to be the worst shot ever simply because ronnie was better is a little bit sad and pathetic.

Dont even start that shit you douche.
Heres what you do, you rifle through the pics till you find one that is bad enough to suit your agenda, then you post it against the best one of Ronnie you can find and proclaim victory.
Well after everyone called you out on it, you starting finding the worst pics you could find at his better contests, that way you can claim its "from his best contest", even though its the one or 2 pics from that contest that dont look that impressive.

And whats even funnier, is youre owning yourself, that comparison Dorian still wins, muscular bulk, balance and conditioning, Dorians only weakness was his biceps, so don't even try that shit.
You can tell Dorian is rediculously thicker than ronnie, just check out the Lats, the shadows under his lats give it away, Dorians lats look like theyre 3 feet thick from the front. Ronnie looks flat as a pancake by comparison.

[James Blunt]

/There is no point in such an argument.

[Game Time]

Dont even start that shit you douche.
Heres what you do, you rifle through the pics till you find one that is bad enough to suit your agenda, then you post it against the best one of Ronnie you can find and proclaim victory.
Well after everyone called you out on it, you starting finding the worst pics you could find at his better contests, that way you can claim its "from his best contest", even though its the one or 2 pics from that contest that dont look that impressive.

And whats even funnier, is youre owning yourself, that comparison Dorian still wins, muscular bulk, balance and conditioning, Dorians only weakness was his biceps, so don't even try that shit.
You can tell Dorian is rediculously thicker than ronnie, just check out the Lats, the shadows under his lats give it away, Dorians lats look like theyre 3 feet thick from the front. Ronnie looks flat as a pancake by comparison.

Are you serious? Dorian was a good BB'er but to compare him to the top BB'er of another era is outrageous. If both Ronnie and Yates were to compete in the next Mr. O (with both of them in their prime) Ronnie would still dominate...Dorian would not even be in the first call out. These are facts

[Wiggs]

putting pics next to each other is cheating Ronnie who at his best was 287lbs in 03.  The best Yates was at 260.  Kinda like how Ronnie dwarfed Jay.  Ronnie would kill him.

[~UN_$ung~]

Are you serious? Dorian was a good BB'er but to compare him to the top BB'er of another era is outrageous. If both Ronnie and Yates were to compete in the next Mr. O (with both of them in their prime) Ronnie would still dominate...Dorian would not even be in the first call out. These are facts

the era wasn't different..........same drugs in the 90s that they have today.....matter of fact they were better, because all the gear was still human grade, and the UGLs didnt take over yet.

training was no different, nutrition was no different........

dorian woudn't be in the first callout???  you can have your opinion that ronnie is the superior bodybuilder..........but dorian consistently dominated in during an era which was by far bodybuilding's most competitive, and he dominated some of the best bodybuilders of all time

the 90s had WAY deeper lineups then  today.........shawn, flex, chris, nasser, kevin

dorian owned those guys in their prime, ronnie dominated them when they were past it

of course dorian would be in the first callout

[Shockwave]

Are you serious? Dorian was a good BB'er but to compare him to the top BB'er of another era is outrageous. If both Ronnie and Yates were to compete in the next Mr. O (with both of them in their prime) Ronnie would still dominate...Dorian would not even be in the first call out. These are facts

Lol. The fact you think Ronnie would dominate shows your lack of BB knowledge. Ill be more than willing to say that it will be a tough fight, but to say one would dominate is rediculous.
Ronnie has just as many flaws as Dorian did, and at their respective bests, Dorian (93 or 95) has Ronnie (98) slightly on size, and conditioning. 2003 I dont think is Ronnies best because his condition suffered so much. But he was huge, no doubt.