But he has health issues stemming from the spider bite. He's never been the same since.
Yeah, that is understandable. I hope Keith reads my posts still, I mean him no harm, and I did not realize the whole story before I acted like a jackass and said things I wished I could take back.
I understand the depression, and I understand being farther from where you want to be than you ever where. I was to the point where I was in bed most of the day. I slept all the time, and sat around being depressed, and I was addicted to food binging. I came to the realization that I had to forgive myself for the past and do my best to move on.
So I was making little goals, like:
1. Get out of bed, prepare my food in advance.
2. Do rehab work for my back.
3. Go check the mail
4. Start going out and shopping during the daylight and not at 3 am.
It went on and on like that. I got comfortable with the little things again, and I made sure to have a slight calorie deficit the whole time. I did mess around with the diet and read a lot about different approaches, and they really are not for me or anyone else really, but in my case, fat loss was the number one priority so the caloric deficit was the constant.
The problem with the 'let's get in shape' mentality is that people change so many things at once and burn themselves out. Keith may believe in the typical 'bodybuilding diet', which is fine. However, when you are depressed, angry, sad, etc. food is your drug, you comfort. Changing all of these things, like going from eating whatever you like to eating nothing but 'healthy' stuff sucks, and there is no gratification in it. It is like you spend a few weeks in hell trying to kick the habit of loving food.
So, in his case, he should just figure up his calories, and eat 500 less a day like normal and see what happens. He could drop them by a thousand if he wanted to, and have a good cheat day 1 time every week or so. He should still eat what he likes, and just do this until the weight stops dropping, then reduce again. Eventually he will be light enough to work out or walk or whatever. It may take him 3-6 months to get to that point, but he will get there.
Then, when he is detoxed from over eating and using food as a drug, he can change what he eats if he wants.
But doing it all at the same time in his mindset is like trying to climb that mountain with a weighted vest and one leg.