Who is better, Roelly Winklaar or Evan Centopani?

[SWOLETRAIN]

I vote the big ass whiteboy 

[the_swami]

Evan vs Roelly

Evan wins because he is Jim Manion's boy
plain and simple

[G_Thang]

As you said, I'm am NOT a fan of Evan, but I think he has some world class arms. What you did say does make sense. I do think that Frank McGrath a better marketing model for Animal than Evan. Frank represented the company model- and coming, hungry, grassroots, underground. He had that edgey old skool blue collar vibe to him. Evan does not, Frank seemed hard working, Evan hardly working. Too bad Frank tore a bicep.

hahaha.

[alnassak]

I like Evan and he looked great last year at the NYP, but I think if he showed up this year the same way he did last year, Roelly would have still be the winner. 

I wish that he had made good improvements this year and looking forward to see it very soon. 

gotta love his side chest pose

[kyomu]

Roelly is a pussymagnet, Centopani stalks bitches on the internet from his moms house.

http://clips.team-andro.com/watch/093f48c7c26980ec4a4c/NYC-Diary-NY-City-Shooting-Thursday

Woa. I thought this was joke until watching this video.

[Robgun1]

peaceful28

I second that.  Stalkerpani followed her around like a puppy for over a year and hacked into her MD account only to find out that John Romano was already schmoeing her. It will be remembered as a legendary moment in bodybuilding that Stalkerpani officially lost his mind and waged war. lmao



http://www.getbig.com/boards/index.php?topic=302197.msg4325554#msg4325554

[Robgun1]

I vote EVAN, in my opinion.. a more pleasant looking physique  (no homo)

correction

[~UN_$ung~]

evan centopani....the great white hype.....is using a good rationale......the longer i do not compete, the longer i can stretch out my initial hype before i am exposed as a charlatan

whomever said it was correct, if he showed up this year like he did last year.........rolley would have buttraped him

[Immortal_Technique]

Who is the better winner of the NY Pro or the better rookie? Okay, many of you know I don't see Evan Centopani as anything but a dude with good arms and legs, bur I think he has no heart. He won the NY Pro last year against a weak field that included a weak Ruhl and DJ, both of whom have been lethal in the past. Roelly, who won his pro card at the Arnold Amatuers last year, placed 7th at the Arnold, 3rd at the Aussie and won the NY Pro. The Arnold was a tough field, and so was the Aussie Pro, the NY Pro was a third tier show, with the respectable type of competitors.

And then there is the thing where one took 18 mos off to prepare, and the other jumped right in, showing that he is game. Oh, and BTW, MattT hates Roelly, me I said, he was going places, like i said Phil was and prior to that Richard Jones.

I think 2 things are interesting about this. Centopani famously had weak legs a couple of years ago, so the fact he's got them big enough for people like you to say they are good says quite a lot about his 'heart', and the value of his time off and concomitant improvements.

People always like the most recent hype and forget about last year's hype, so you are one of the people who next year will say Roelly is 'done' and next year's NY winner is the future.

As a side note, it seems intelligent to take some time off to improve, in a Dorian Yates style, if necessary. Yes Roelly beat the mighty Hide (who looked phenominal, probably should have won, but isn't really top tier pro is he?) and an off Wolf and Freeman, but his condition is inferior to Centopani. We'll see I guess, Roelly probably has better genes and may go further in the long run, but Centopani's dilligence is to be commended.

[Parker]

I think 2 things are interesting about this. Centopani famously had weak legs a couple of years ago, so the fact he's got them big enough for people like you to say they are good says quite a lot about his 'heart', and the value of his time off and concomitant improvements.

People always like the most recent hype and forget about last year's hype, so you are one of the people who next year will say Roelly is 'done' and next year's NY winner is the future.

As a side note, it seems intelligent to take some time off to improve, in a Dorian Yates style, if necessary. Yes Roelly beat the mighty Hide (who looked phenominal, probably should have won, but isn't really top tier pro is he?) and an off Wolf and Freeman, but his condition is inferior to Centopani. We'll see I guess, Roelly probably has better genes and may go further in the long run, but Centopani's dilligence is to be
commended.

good observation. But, I don't bandwagon and jump on hype.
I had said last yr that Roelly was one to watch. Others doubted me. I had said that Phil wasxone to watch. Prior to that, I was saying Richard Jones, prior to him winning his pro card. I am a fan of Omar Deckard and Lionel Brown, two guys who haven't produced, but can do so. Also Brandon Curry.
I think Auguste will get his pro card as well.

Another dude watch would be Ben Paluski and Fankhouser.
Hide is not mighty, Hide has structural and aesthetic and separation problems. He fan only out condition third tier pros, after that he is nothing big...there are Japanese dudes out there blow Hide away.

About Centopani, getting his legs big is one thing in the off season, having them big when diet down is another. Melvin has this problem, as does Deshawn Grimes.

[Immortal_Technique]

good observation. But, I don't bandwagon and jump on hype.
I had said last yr that Roelly was one to watch. Others doubted me. I had said that Phil wasxone to watch. Prior to that, I was saying Richard Jones, prior to him winning his pro card. I am a fan of Omar Deckard and Lionel Brown, two guys who haven't produced, but can do so. Also Brandon Curry.
I think Auguste will get his pro card as well.

Another dude watch would be Ben Paluski and Fankhouser.
Hide is not mighty, Hide has structural and aesthetic and separation problems. He fan only out condition third tier pros, after that he is nothing big...there are Japanese dudes out there blow Hide away.

About Centopani, getting his legs big is one thing in the off season, having them big when diet down is another. Melvin has this problem, as does Deshawn Grimes.

Okay fair enough. But if Hide is so bad then why is everyone saying Roelly beat such a good field at the NY? Hide came 2nd. So if the field was strong he must be a strong competitor? If he blows then it was a blowy field surely?

I agree Evan lost a bunch of leg size dieting down for the NY, but he understood ripped hams and glutes are more important that insanely massive quads. There was still major progress, and I still think the guy has serious heart. His conditioning is a bunch better than Melvin. I'm only concerned his waiste is expanding with all the heavy squats. Roelly has awesome shape and size. We'll see if he can get that hard-as-nails look he'll need to beat the Dexters and Kai Greens.

[Parker]

Maybe his yr's field is better than last yr's.  But both yrs have a pretty weak field in general. This ur'sxfield was hyped because of Toney and Wolf... Big men tend to hype shows. Plus Hide just came off of a win.

[Ex Coelis]

Hide looked great and compared very well

can't take that away from him

[Parker]

Hide looked great and compared very well

can't take that away from him

Yes he compared favorably well to a lineup of bloated, blown gut having, sacks of third rate shit. The NY Pro is not like the NOC of old, it is a embarassing third tier  show.

[kiwiol]

Evan has a bit of a wide waist, but not so much that it throws off his overall look, as is the case with guys like Paco or Atwood. Roelly has freaky arms and legs, but his midsection looked terrible in the NY Pro and he has a weak back, which isn't very easy to improve. He looks great in the precontest pics when standing by himself (a la Dennis James), but loses that presence onstage, when he's compared with other guys.

Only major problem for Evan is his waist, but Jay Cutler has a similar problem and still managed to win the Olympia, although Jay has wider shoulders and a better taper. If Evan improves his taper, he'll be better than Roelly.

[Parker]

Good analysis! Although it was shown that Roelly's midsection looked better when he doesn't crunch down in the FDB. Also his back has improve.

[240 is Back]

Evan hates dieting, and will probably do 4 shows in the next 5 years.

Roelly will do 5 or 7 shows a year.

[SWOLETRAIN]

NYP was the best Rolley we will ever see. Hes maxed out, like a hidetada. I think if he gets bigger its gonna be the start of the downward spiral. And if he stays the same hes not a threat on the o stage. Hes no dexter jackson. Evan is a young swole whiteboy with semi good white guy genetics like cutler. Nobody ever thought cutler would be the guy to beat? Evan can pack the mass on it takes to be a top contender. IMO its just a matter of time...

[bodybuilder1234]

Its really hard to look at Roelly and actually like him, he just looks like a chinese black man with down-syndrome.
It also makes me sick to my stomach when he poses, hes squints his eyes and the wrinkles in his face pop out making him look like a certified retard.

The guy seems like a complete dumbass also, especially in his eating vid
His so called "fans" get to watch him for the first time and the dude doesnt say a word, i mean how fucking hard is it to say "thank you for my fans who supported me?".

Roelly is just some ugly mongrel who crawled out of some shithole somewhere, abit like Golem from lord of the rings.
I mean, look at this thing.....again it fucking makes me sick to my stomach