picking that and Alan Wake up as well
I've been playing Alan Wake most of this week. It's good. I don't see many casual gamers really enjoying it though. The story telling, so far, is pretty damn great. The acting is a little weird at times but it isn't immersion breaking. The atmosphere of the game is creepy enough that it makes it hard for me to play for long periods of time. yeah, i'm a wuss like that.
I picked up RDR today. Haven't had the chance to test it out yet. Still have AW to finish, last part of Fallout 3, and then I can move on to my next one.
Have you played Heavy Rain yet? I want to give that a whirl big time. Also, GoW3 was awesome. Shit end though.