Seriously? How can you look at that pic and think Jay is better? Because he's bigger? Look at his waist for God sake. Not to mention that his right leg is nonexistent. You probably like Evan Centopani's hair too.
Right leg nonexistent? Compare it to Dexter. The only thing nonexistent is Dexter's calves. Even the female version of Olympia has better calves. And that's not hyperbole, my friend.
You act like it's not even close. But it just goes to show how subjective the sport is. Fact is, Jay won. Easily. This win was his least controversial. Those that were there say he just dominated the stage. Even our "never wrong" resident god of hormones, gh15, said that Jay proved him wrong.
Compared to Dex, I think not only is Jay bigger -- way bigger -- but also better. And so did the judges and the majority of the fans.
Seriously.