Sincerely, judgement level in USA is simply a joke. When anyone can win it depends three causes:
1 His name and the sponsor´s name too... Looks like a names competition, not a bodies competition.
2 His Passport, if isn´t from USA, several points less, unless you can go throug the cuestion above, number 1...
3 Condition... It all depends from points 1 and 2... If you are shredred but you don´t have point 1 and 2, it doesn´t matter, you can win.
Paco has not good shape. But bodybuilding is something more, cutting, big and proportions are importants things too. Shape is a structure, nature gives but the rest is work, hard work, dieting and being disciplinated. USA Judges only can see points 1 to 3.
In Europe, Paco in the same competition, would be 3th o 4th at least.