I agree. Some of the pics make it seem like Jay looked better, which he only did because Ronnie relaxed his midsection and was a terrible poser. But if you watch the video, you can see Ronnie had enough size, separation and muscularity to (narrowly) beat Jay. Ronnie also improved a lot for the finals compared to his prejudging shape, while Jay went the opposite way a bit.
I think Jay looked better in the 2001 Mr Olympia than he has in the last 4-5 years, sans 2009.