i think his whole win that year in retrospect was ridiculous. i'm guessing the judges realized over the course of the year that everyone was upset about jay's '07 victory so they had already made up their minds to give it to someone else as punishment or something. could have also been fixed.
If that is how the judges were thinking, then they ought to be given the flick.
If they can't judge the best PHYSIQUE on the day - irrespective of name - than what on earth are they 'judging' for?
In my opinion, Dexter has been getting the shaft recently. He must have done a Samir.