In my teens in highschool, fucking a girl was just that, dick in vag. Never thought about doing anal and the girls never thought of asking for it. Then again the internet at that time was 28k modems so streaming porn online didn't exist and VHS cassettes were in.
Even college it wasn't so much until I banged a professor. She was this sexy 40 year old who would constantly ask me to pound her ass. It seemed gross at the time. I didn't care for it much since she'd let me fuck her raw in the vag but had to bag it for her ass. It really wasn't into late into my 20's that I started wanting to pound them in the ass. It seemed the more of a whore they were the more I wanted to pound their ass.
Discuss...
The first time )actually not the first) that's another virginity story, any this was my first gf I fucked in the arse- I was 16 & my gf 15, and I plugged her right in the butt, no lube or nothing, just youthful exuberance and a she'll be right attitude! Well, she took it like a trooper and didn't squeal at what occurs to me now to be a very painful experience for her, fortunately for my gf and not for me, her Mother and her stepdad came home, and shortly after the mum walked in while I was chock up her daughter. My Gf was relieved, my gf mum and i were shocked (+I was a bit turned on by it all cause the mum was young and hot) the mum quickly closed the door, I slipped out of my gf, reall embarrased and scared to go out and face the stepdad. So I dressed and jumped out the windows and rode my pushbike home - True Story
This is well before the days of mobile phones and internet and the like, so I don't know what girls you were hanging around with, but in my neighbourhood 20 odd years ago, the were some great sluts getting around (God Bless em)