I just finished watching and I really enjoyed it.
I like that you guys expressed your open views like when Peter said "I have no clue how they gave Branch the best poser award." I know Chick went on to explain it, but if something like this show gains a bit of popularity, it'll start to hold the judges more accountable. People are always complaining about "politics" and blah blah blah, but if a respected brand like MD in the industry has a show where respectable contributors to the bodybuilding community like Bob Chick have free range to say things like "Ummmm, not sure hot the judges made that decision," it'll obviously impact the way judges call things by holding them more accountable.
The concept of the show is solid overall. Obviously just getting started and will be a work in progress, but a lot of potential there really.
Hope to see this take off. Good luck Chick!