As for Dorian doing low reps, going too heavy and unsound training, I've watched Blood N guts and he does 3 sets of pushdowns (12,10,11 reps) 2 sets of skullcrushers (6 reps each) and finished it off with 1 set of one arm pushdowns (1 set per arm) for 8 reps (with a little help to squeeze at the last 1-2 reps)
That doesn't come across to me as going overboard. Injuries can happen for a number of reasons.
Exactly; Lee Priest is famous for his 5 sets of 6-8 reps style of training. I don't see his body riddled with injuries, and who's going to tell me he could be 'better' with 12-15 reps?
Dorian's form is as good as anyone's in the history of the sport; while overloading his body pre-Olympias probably didn't do him any favours, chances are with ANY training style (assuming he ultimately lifted as or near to as heavy) he would have injured himself as his body was just built that way. In
A Warrior's Story he concludes that were his form not as strict, he'd have injured himself earlier and more severely.
Yates' injuries and cause (once he'd established his HIT-based methodology):
March 7, 1994 - injured ligament on the rotator cuff in left shoulder doing *warm-up set* of decline presses
April, 1994 - tore vastus muscle in left thigh
July 12, 1994 - torn bicep doing 405-pound barbell rows
June, 1997 - small tear in right thigh doing leg extensions while suffering from mysterious illness; later, turned out to be tear in the wall of his stomach from taking too much aspirin
October, 1997 - tears left tricep doing pullover-and-press
If you look at the bulking exercises he did, most of them were relatively 'safe' - Smith Machine to the front shoulder presses, hack squates, leg presses, Smith Machine squats, Incline bench press, only a couple of sets of deads (after being *thoroughly* warmed up), etc.
I think the fair conclusion is he both pushed it and was plain fucking unlucky.
Why all the hate on Dorian, Pumpster? No matter what the thread is, if he's mentioned you pop up and start taking shots at the guy. Wait... you're not a Shawn Ray alias are you!?