I like both of them, and will cast a vote for neither to leave (yes, that's right). Ego-driven conflict is entertaining, so why vote to reduce it?
As for the hate on E-Kul, I do believe it is because he effectively argues his points, and has managed to piss-off so many people along the way. And while I absolutely disagree with his generalizations of Muslims, he is entitled to go through his processes - just like we all are. He's usually a brilliant poster.