5'8" 200 under 10% but build and density are EVERYTHING. wide shoulders 18" neck , 18" arms. a 5'8" underwear model never gets noticed in clothes and looks small its the guy with powerful build who gets looks and envy. unfortunately u have to lift heavy and be strong to achieve this.
i dunno.... when i'm smaller (leaner) i don't look all that impressive in clothes.. my neck rarely goes below 18, but when i take off my shirt i get 'what the fuck' comments.. shirt comes off and i look like i put on 15lbs.
some guys just don't look 'great' in clothes... look at shawn ray, or darrem Charles, or even dexter Jackson or milos..... then look at Nasser or dante, or kevin English or jose Raymond.
... fuck, i was in a hurry and forgot what my point was gonna be. lol
it all depends on your frame. i have a small frame.. super small wrists, my waist can get down to 30/31 at 195 or so... my triceps are long (biceps are short though) and my delts are big and round .... one of my employees is the same height and weight and fairly lean, but i look like i have 40lbs on him. (his quads blow mine away though in overall size, although his are fat... he does have some dorian calves though).