Most ludicrous judging decision ever in BB?

[onlyme]

Rusty Jeffers not getting called out and compared to Bob Chick......

bump that

[jaejonna]

Austraila 2005 ....

Racism won that year

[brianX]

Tim Belknap winning the 1981 AAU Mr. America.

[MikeThaMachine]

Rusty Jeffers not getting called out and compared to Bob Chick......

In recent times this is by far the most ludicrous of them all








And Cormier not getting atleast 2-3 ASC

[G o a t b o y]

I would have to say Bertil Fox placing fifth at the '83 Olympia would be way up there.  He deserved no less than second.

Any other notables?

[delta9mda]

The difference between 2001 and 1994 is this:

2001 was still debatable. It was close, and everyone can see that.

 On the other hand, I don't think anyone in their right mind (except ND who is on crack anyway) thinks that 1994 was undebatable. It was a robbery, plain and simple. Everyone has been saying that for years.  There was no debate about that.

I have never really heard anyone make a sound case for Dorian winning in the kind of shape that he was in 1994, especiall with Shawn ray showing up looking like he did.. I mean look at that shot from the contest that I posted - that is, in my opinion, THE greatest arms forward most muscular ever, even better than Kevin! 

no, cutler going in to the night show winning by 6 and then losing?
yates was ahead in 94 all the way and correct me if im wrong but wasnt shawn in 3rd till the night show?

[NarcissisticDeity]

no, cutler going in to the night show winning by 6 and then losing?
yates was ahead in 94 all the way and correct me if im wrong but wasnt shawn in 3rd till the night show?

No you're right after the prejudging Shawn Ray was BEHIND Kevin Levrone and he only passed him with a ' better ' posing routine , Dorian won both the muscularity & symmetry rounds with straight firsts

2001 Jay Cutler won both the muscularity & symmetry rounds and lost the posing rounds thats NEVER been done in a Mr Olympia contest , NO Mr Olympia winner has ever gone into the nightshow trailing by 6 points and won , this is what makes this contest the biggest joke aside 1980/1981/2002

[dzulboy]

Arnold winning the 1980 Olympia

agreed

[Eyeball Chambers]

In words of 96 republican pres nominee , Bob Dole (who I voted for)
" Bob Dole knows Jay won that Olympia, the senate and congress know it, the IFBB knows it and by GOD the American people know it."

HAHA he said that? BS, really?

[Saxon]

  Ronnie should only have won the 98 and 99 Os. From there, he only went downhill.

SUCKMYMUSCLE

He should not have won in 98 (or was it 99), he had clearly visable gyno. Actually having a Mr. O with gyno is probably the most ludicrous bodybuilding decision ever.

[sculpture]

He should not have won in 98 (or was it 99), he had clearly visable gyno. Actually having a Mr. O with gyno is probably the most ludicrous bodybuilding decision ever.

In that case franco columbo of 1981 qualifies as the most ludicrous decisision of all time. Gyno like ronnie but unlike ronnie didnt actually have a single line of separation in his quads.

Gyno.

No quads. Actually one bigger than the other.

No calves.

Receding hairline.

Notably impoverished countenance.

Appalling decision.

[the shadow]

Dorian displaying no right bicep in 96

does any one have dorians posing routine from olympia 1996 ?if any one have it please post it via rapidshare...that posing routine was the best ever...no questions asked

[sculpture]

does any one have dorians posing routine from olympia 1996 ?if any one have it please post it via rapidshare...that posing routine was the best ever...no questions asked

He looks dreadful in that shot.

Complete ownage in the front dbl bi by both men flanking him,

[Vince B]

Bev Francis coming 8th in her first big bodybuilding contest in 83 was ludicrous. Carla Dunlop won and Rachel McLish was third in that controversial show. Ben Weider literally did not know what to do with Bev but they felt her image was not good for women's bodybuilding.

Then there was Franco winning the 81 Oympia in poor condition. Arnold probably was the best in 80 but not by much. Lots of guys could have won that day. However, Sergio was robbed several times and especially in Germany in 1972. Also, Bill Pearl beating Sergio in 1971 in the NABBA Pro. One judge put Sergio down because he said Sergio's head was too small for the size of his arms! Bob Gajda beating Sergio in the 66 Mr America. Sergio went over to the IFBB after that.

[jarhead]

I didn't know who the hell Sasha Ogata was.  I actually have the muscular development where she/he/person? is on the cover.  Fooled me.  Fooled a lot of people.

Maybe because of I've never seen it/he/she  whatever? in person and now only in pictures but is seems I would have thought it was female for sure.

[rocket]

Surely it was Vince Goodrum not getting last.

[the shadow]

He looks dreadful in that shot.

Complete ownage in the front dbl bi by both men flanking him,

shut up you ass..dorian yates looked awesome at the olympia 1996..his condtion was beyond the reach of levrone or nasser or any body else..he looked too much gariny and still looked big enough..
UR FUCKING BLIND...